Best Smile.io Alternatives for Shopify

Eight Smile.io alternatives for Shopify compared on price, free plans, VIP tiers and what each is best for, with every plan read from the app's own Shopify App Store listing on 19 November 2026.
Last updated on
Published on
November 19, 2026
•
17
minutes
Best Smile.io Alternatives for Shopify

Smile.io is the loyalty app most Shopify stores meet first - and for plenty of them it stays the right call. So why does every other app vendor publish a “Smile.io alternatives” list? Because three limits tend to show up at about the same time: VIP tiers start at $199 a month, the free plan stops at 200 orders with no integrations, and unlimited integrations only arrive at $199 too.

The short answer: the best Smile.io alternative depends on what you want to change. Growave is best for growing Shopify brands that want to increase loyalty, retention and repeat purchases, with strong Shopify POS and Klaviyo integrations. LoyaltyLion is best for mid-size brands that want a customised program and the widest free plan (400 orders). Rivo suits low-volume stores that want VIP tiers early. BON lists a flat-rate plan for high order volumes. Joy suits loyalty-first stores that want 250 free orders. Yotpo, Okendo and Stamped make the most sense if you already run their review products.

Full disclosure: we make Growave, so we list it first and say plainly where it isn’t the best fit. Every plan and price below comes straight from the app’s own Shopify App Store listing, checked on 19 November 2026.

Plan prices, order limits and ratings were read from each app’s Shopify App Store listing on 19 November 2026. A listed price is the starting point for each tier - most apps add a charge per extra 100 orders, so what you pay depends on your volume. Confirm in the listing before you switch.

Here’s what we’ll cover:

  • What Smile.io costs today and where merchants hit its limits
  • 8 alternatives, each with a “best for” line, current pricing and an honest trade-off
  • How to choose - and where integrations decide repeat purchases
  • How to switch without losing points

Smile.io alternatives at a glance

AppBest forFree planVIP tiers - listed fromReviews and wishlist built inApp Store rating
Smile.io (baseline)Simple, polished, loyalty-only program200 orders/mo$199 (Growth)No - integrates with review apps4.9 (4,682), Built for Shopify
GrowaveGrowing brands that want more loyalty, retention and repeat purchases200 orders/mo (loyalty, plus wishlist and reviews)$199 (Growth)Yes - from the free plan4.8 (1,287), Built for Shopify
LoyaltyLionMid-size brands wanting a customised program400 orders/mo$199 (Classic, per listing)No4.7 (552)
YotpoBrands already on Yotpo Reviews or SMSUnder 100 orders/moNot named on the $199 Pro plan - confirm with YotpoReviews are a separate Yotpo product4.7 (965)
RivoLow-volume stores wanting VIP tiers early200 orders/mo$49 (Scale, 400 orders included, then $20 per 100)No reviews; wishlists only inside Rivo Accounts ($499)4.7 (1,440)
JoyLoyalty-first stores wanting 250 free orders250 orders/mo$129 (Advanced, 2,000 orders included)No - integrates with review apps4.9 (1,783), Built for Shopify
BONFlat-rate plan at high order volume150 orders/mo$129 (Growth, listed as unlimited orders)No - integrates with review apps5.0 (1,938), Built for Shopify
OkendoBrands where reviews come first50 orders/mo (Reviews plan)Loyalty is a separate product - Okendo says from $99Reviews yes, wishlist no4.8 (1,455)
StampedBrands already on Stamped ReviewsNone listed (Reviews from $23)Loyalty is sold via stamped.io, not on the App Store listingReviews yes (separate subscription), wishlist no4.7 (3,752)

Why Shopify brands look for a Smile.io alternative

Let’s be fair first. Smile.io is a strong app: it holds 4.9 stars from more than 4,600 reviews on the Shopify App Store, carries the Built for Shopify badge and won a 2026 Shopify Build Award. So what pushes merchants to look elsewhere? Usually one of these:

  • VIP tiers start at $199 a month. VIP tiers and points expiry arrive on the Growth plan, which includes 2,500 orders and then charges $20 per 100 more.
  • The free plan is small. It covers 200 orders a month, and Smile’s pricing page shows no integrations on it - so no Klaviyo connection until you pay.
  • Integrations are gated by plan. Essential includes 1, Standard 2, and unlimited arrive on Growth. If you want Klaviyo, a reviews app and a helpdesk connected, you reach $199 quickly.
  • API access sits at the top. The API comes with Smile Plus at $999 a month, billed annually, for up to 7,500 orders.
  • The target customer has moved up. Smile’s own site now describes the product as built for Shopify Plus and enterprise brands. A growing brand may not feel like the audience anymore.

Smile.io pricing in November 2026

Before comparing, here is the baseline. These are the plans on Smile’s Shopify App Store listing, with the Plus and Enterprise tiers taken from Smile’s pricing page.

Smile: Loyalty Program Rewards - first image on its Shopify App Store listing
Smile’s Shopify App Store listing (4.9 from 4,682 reviews). Image source
  • Free - 200 orders a month: points, referrals, discount and free-shipping rewards, full branding, native Shopify POS.
  • Essential, $15 a month - 500 orders: dedicated loyalty page, free product rewards, nudges, analytics, Shopify Flow, 1 integration.
  • Standard, $79 a month - 1,000 orders: bonus events, points on product pages, subscription and gift card rewards, 2 integrations.
  • Growth, $199 a month - 2,500 orders, then $20 per 100: VIP tiers and points expiry, Loyalty Hub, redeem at checkout (Shopify Plus), benchmarks, unlimited integrations.
  • Smile Plus, $999 a month (annual billing) - 7,500 orders, API access and priority support. Enterprise is custom.

Best for: stores that want the simplest launch on a polished loyalty app.

The 8 best Smile.io alternatives for Shopify

1. Growave - best for growing brands that want to increase loyalty, retention and repeat purchases

Growave is a loyalty and retention platform for Shopify brands. Points, VIP tiers and referrals run the program, and it is built to meet customers where repeat purchases actually happen: at the register through Shopify POS, in the inbox through Klaviyo, and at checkout. Reviews and wishlists sit on the same customer profile, so they can feed the program instead of living in separate apps.

Growave: Loyalty and Wishlist - first image on its Shopify App Store listing
Growave’s Shopify App Store listing (4.8 from 1,287 reviews, Built for Shopify). Image source

Pricing (App Store listing, 19 Nov 2026):

  • Free - 200 orders a month: loyalty points program, plus wishlist and product reviews.
  • Entry, $15 a month - 500 orders, then $20 per 100: advanced rewards, referral program with fraud protection, nudges, review request email series, Shopify POS and Shopify Flow, +1 integration (for example Klaviyo).
  • Growth, $199 a month - 1,500 orders, then $15 per 100: VIP tiers and store credit (online and POS), custom loyalty page design, POS Loyalty QR and Apple/Google Wallet, Boost campaigns and gift cards, Google Shopping reviews and Instagram UGC, back-in-stock wishlist emails.
  • Plus, $499 a month - 3,000 orders, then $10 per 100: checkout extensions, headless API and SDK, B2B points and wishlists, custom reward actions, unlimited integrations, a customer success manager.

Paid plans come with a 14-day trial.

Where it beats Smile.io:

  • In store: the POS Loyalty QR lets staff identify a member at the register by scanning a code, and Shopify POS is part of the plan from Entry ($15).
  • In the inbox: every loyalty event - points earned, tier changed, points expiring - fires into Klaviyo, with pre-built flows you can clone.
  • Under the hood: checkout extensions and the headless API and SDK arrive on Plus at $499 a month for up to 3,000 orders; on Smile, the API starts at Plus, $999 for up to 7,500 orders.

Trade-off: VIP tiers still start at Growth, $199 a month - the same price as Smile.io - and Growth includes 1,500 orders where Smile’s includes 2,500. Like every app here, the bill grows with your order volume. Growave is also Shopify-only.

2. LoyaltyLion - best for mid-size brands that want a customised program

LoyaltyLion is a loyalty specialist, and it leans into hands-on setup. Its listing says it is trusted by more than 10,000 Shopify brands.

LoyaltyLion - first screenshot on its Shopify App Store listing
LoyaltyLion’s Shopify App Store listing (4.7 from 552 reviews). Image source

Pricing (App Store listing, 19 Nov 2026):

  • Free - 400 orders a month: points for on-site activities, money-off and percentage rewards, branding options, loyalty analytics and customer segments, 7 languages.
  • Classic, $199 a month - free loyalty page design worth $1,500, customisable rules and rewards, unlimited integrations, onboarding support, VIP loyalty tiers, POS locations, loyalty-attributed revenue reporting, Klaviyo loyalty flows built for you.
  • Above 500 orders a month, Advanced and Plus are custom quotes.

Where it beats Smile.io: the free plan is twice as large (400 orders against 200), and the loyalty page design and Klaviyo flows are done for you on Classic.

Trade-off: once you pass 500 orders a month you are into custom pricing, so you won’t know your real cost until you get a quote. Confirm which plan includes VIP tiers before you buy.

3. Yotpo - best for brands already running Yotpo Reviews or SMS

Yotpo Loyalty is one product in a wider platform that also sells Reviews and SMS. If you are already in that ecosystem, keeping loyalty with the same vendor is the draw. (We compared it head to head in Yotpo vs Smile.io vs Growave.)

Yotpo: Loyalty Rewards Program - first screenshot on its Shopify App Store listing
Yotpo’s Shopify App Store listing (4.7 from 965 reviews). Image source

Pricing (App Store listing, 19 Nov 2026):

  • Free - for stores with fewer than 100 monthly orders: rewards sticky bar, points for purchases, points exchanged for discounts, referral program, reporting, AI chat support.
  • Pro, $199 a month - from 500 orders a month at $0.08 to $0.20 per order: rewards page, additional ways to earn, more rewards, redeem points at checkout, webhooks, extra integrations, email support.
  • Premium and Enterprise are custom - see Yotpo’s pricing page.

Where it beats Smile.io: one vendor if you already use Yotpo’s review or SMS products.

Trade-off: the free plan caps at under 100 orders, pricing is per-order from 500, and the Pro plan list on the App Store doesn’t name VIP tiers - ask Yotpo which plan includes them. Reviews are sold separately.

4. Rivo - best for low-volume stores that want VIP tiers early

Rivo is a Shopify-only loyalty and referrals app. Its VIP tiers are listed from $49 a month - but read the small print before you compare that with a $199 plan.

Rivo: Loyalty Program, Rewards - first image on its Shopify App Store listing
Rivo’s Shopify App Store listing (4.7 from 1,440 reviews). Image source

Pricing (App Store listing, 19 Nov 2026):

  • Free - 200 orders a month: loyalty points program, ways to earn and redeem, branding, automated emails.
  • Essential, $15 a month - 500 orders: loyalty and referral page, theme extensions, on-site prompts, 2 integrations, Shopify POS integration, 24/7 human support.
  • Scale, $49 a month - includes 400 orders, then $20 per 100, capped at $499: VIP tiers, points expiry, analytics, bonus campaigns, referral program, advanced branding.
  • Plus, $499 a month - up to 2,500 orders: custom integrations, advanced analytics, developer toolkit, checkout extensions.

Where it beats Smile.io: at low order volumes, VIP tiers are listed from $49 against $199.

Trade-off: that $49 includes only 400 orders. At 1,500 orders a month the listing’s own numbers give $269 ($49 plus 11 blocks of $20) - about the same ground as the $199 plans. Rivo’s pricing page also sells Cashback ($199) and Accounts ($499, where wishlists live) as separate products.

5. Joy - best for loyalty-first stores that want 250 free orders

Joy is a loyalty app built by Avada. Its Shopify listing is rated 4.9 from 1,783 reviews, carries the Built for Shopify badge and says the app is free for up to 250 orders a month.

Joy Loyalty Program Rewards - first screenshot on its Shopify App Store listing
Joy’s Shopify App Store listing (4.9 from 1,783 reviews, Built for Shopify). Image source

Pricing (App Store listing, 19 Nov 2026):

  • Starter - free, 250 orders a month: flexible points and rewards program, referral program with fraud prevention, loyalty widget, on-brand loyalty design, email reward notifications, 24/7 live chat.
  • Essential, $29 a month - 500 orders, then $15 per 100: points for social engagement, dedicated loyalty page, point expiration rules, 30+ integrations, Shopify Flow automation, analytics.
  • Advanced, $129 a month - 2,000 orders, then $10 per 100: VIP and B2B tiers, loyalty rule engine, bonus point campaigns, redeem in the cart drawer, Loyalty Hub, POS loyalty extension, Apple and Google Wallet passes, paid membership programs.
  • Ultimate, $499 a month - 7,000 orders, then $5 per 100: checkout extensions, developer toolkit and JS SDK, REST API, unlimited integrations, headless support.
  • Paid plans include a free trial.

Where it beats Smile.io: the free plan is bigger (250 orders against 200), and the Advanced plan lists VIP and B2B tiers with 2,000 orders included.

Trade-off: integrations start on Essential, not the free plan, and its listing names Judge.me and Loox as the way to add reviews.

6. BON - best for stores that want a flat-rate plan at high order volume

BON is a loyalty app with a 5.0 rating from 1,938 reviews and the Built for Shopify badge.

BON Loyalty Program and Rewards - first image on its Shopify App Store listing
BON’s Shopify App Store listing (5.0 from 1,938 reviews, Built for Shopify). Image source

Pricing (App Store listing, 19 Nov 2026):

  • Free - 150 orders a month: points and rewards, anti-cheat referral program, automated emails, discount and free-shipping rewards.
  • Starter, $15 a month - 300 orders: dedicated loyalty page, free product rewards, birthday rewards, points expiration, Klaviyo and review-app integrations.
  • Basic, $29 a month - 500 orders: Shopify POS, limited-time offers, advanced nudges, multi-language display, analytics, unlimited integrations.
  • Growth, $129 a month - the listing shows unlimited monthly orders: VIP and B2B tiers, streak and daily check-in points, anniversary rewards, points on the product page.

Where it beats Smile.io: a flat-rate plan with no order cap listed, and a 5.0 rating. One merchant review on the listing describes a migration from Smile with about 30,000 customers: complex, but well supported.

Trade-off: the listing shows five languages (English, German, Spanish, French, Japanese), and a listed “unlimited” plan is worth confirming - check how BON counts orders and what is excluded before you rely on it.

7. Okendo - best when reviews come first

Okendo is a reviews platform that added loyalty, referrals, quizzes and surveys. It is the right shape if reviews are your main job and loyalty is the second.

Okendo: Reviews and Loyalty - first image on its Shopify App Store listing
Okendo’s Shopify App Store listing (4.8 from 1,455 reviews). Image source

Pricing (App Store listing, 19 Nov 2026): the plans on the listing are Reviews plans - Free (50 orders), Essential $19 (200 orders), Growth $119 (1,500 orders) and Power $299 (3,500 orders). Loyalty is a separate Okendo product, and Okendo’s own pricing comparison says it starts at $99 a month. So be careful when you see “from $19” quoted for Okendo loyalty - that is the Reviews entry price.

Where it beats Smile.io: reviews, AI review summaries and loyalty with one vendor.

Trade-off: two subscriptions to model, and no wishlist.

8. Stamped - best if you already use Stamped Reviews

Stamped is a reviews-first platform. Its Shopify listing is now Stamped Product Reviews and UGC, rated 4.7 from 3,752 reviews, with plans from $23 a month. Loyalty is a separate Stamped product sold through stamped.io: the old Stamped Loyalty and Referrals listing says it is no longer available on the Shopify App Store.

Stamped Product Reviews and UGC - first screenshot on its Shopify App Store listing
Stamped’s Shopify App Store listing (4.7 from 3,752 reviews). Image source

Pricing (App Store listing, 19 Nov 2026): Reviews cost $23 a month for 200 orders, $99 for 1,000, $199 for 5,000 and $399 for 20,000. Loyalty pricing isn’t published on the listing - check stamped.io/pricing, where each Stamped product has its own subscription.

Where it beats Smile.io: one vendor for reviews, photo and video UGC, Google Shopping and Meta syndication - and loyalty too, if you buy it.

Trade-off: you can’t install and test Stamped loyalty from the App Store, there is no free plan on the listing, and there is no wishlist.

Which Smile.io alternative should you pick?

  • You want to grow loyalty, retention and repeat purchases, with strong Shopify POS and Klaviyo integrations: Growave.
  • You want a customised program and a large free plan: LoyaltyLion.
  • Your order volume is low and you want VIP tiers early: Rivo - but check the per-100 overage as you grow.
  • You want a flat-rate plan at high volume: BON - confirm how orders are counted.
  • You want the biggest free plan among loyalty-first apps with a trial path: LoyaltyLion (400 orders) or Joy (250).
  • You already run a reviews platform: Yotpo, Okendo or Stamped - same vendor, separate subscription.
  • You only need the basics, simply: stay on Smile.io. Seriously.

Loyalty that brings customers back: where integrations decide repeat purchases

A loyalty program only lifts repeat purchases if customers meet it at the moments that matter - at the register, in their inbox, at checkout. That is where the app you pick earns its price, so check these three before you decide:

  • In store. Does it identify members at the register without a manual search? Growave’s POS Loyalty QR does it by scan, and Smile, Rivo, BON and Joy all list Shopify POS support too - the difference is which plan it sits on.
  • In the inbox. Do loyalty events trigger your emails? With Growave, points earned, tier changes and expiring points all fire into Klaviyo, and you can clone pre-built flows. LoyaltyLion also builds Klaviyo flows for you on Classic.
  • At checkout and beyond. Can members redeem without leaving checkout, and can your developers reach the data? Compare the plan where checkout extensions and the API start - Growave Plus at $499 against Smile Plus at $999.

What does that look like in practice? In our State of Loyalty report, built on behavioural data from 227 Shopify stores, each store’s own repeat purchase rate rose from 15.46% to 18.99% six months after installing Growave (+23%), and from 11.93% to 13.51% after three months (+13%). That is the combined effect of the install, not any single feature, and it compares each store with itself. See the full 2026 loyalty report.

The same report is a useful reality check on VIP tiers. Customers placed in a tier had an average order value of $260 against $125 for non-tiered customers, and bought 2.41 times against 1.16. That compares tiered customers with everyone else, so read it as what an engaged tier looks like rather than proof that tiers cause the gap.

Individual brands show the same pattern. Andiata, a Finnish womenswear brand, saw repeat purchases grow 19.2% in the six months after it installed Growave. North Outdoor connected Growave’s loyalty program to Shopify POS and QR codes and saw in-store redemptions rise 44%; no baseline or date range is published, so read that as direction, not a benchmark. Read the Andiata case study or the North Outdoor case study.

How to switch from Smile.io without losing points

  1. Audit your program. Note your points liability, tier rules, referral settings and any bonus campaigns running.
  2. Price each option at your own order volume. Check your monthly orders against each plan’s included orders and overage rate - listed prices are only the starting point.
  3. Ask for a points and tier import. Member balances, tiers and referral history should move across before you cancel anything. Growave’s team handles the import.
  4. Rebuild earn and redeem rules. Match the old values first, then improve them once members are settled.
  5. Reconnect Klaviyo and your other tools. Loyalty events should fire into your email platform from day one.
  6. Run both briefly, then tell members. A short overlap and a clear email avoid angry points questions.

Conclusion

Smile.io isn’t a bad app - it is just built for a particular stage. If your priorities are a larger free plan, a flat-rate plan or a vendor you already use for reviews, one of the apps above will fit better. If your goal is more loyalty, retention and repeat purchases from a growing store - with POS and Klaviyo wired in - that is what Growave is for. You can install it free from the Shopify App Store or book a demo and we’ll show you how it would look on your store.

FAQ

What is the best alternative to Smile.io for Shopify?

It depends on what you want to change. Growave suits growing brands that want to increase loyalty, retention and repeat purchases, with Shopify POS and Klaviyo integrations. LoyaltyLion suits mid-size brands that want a customised program. Rivo suits low-volume stores that want VIP tiers early, and BON lists a flat-rate Growth plan for high order volumes.

Is there a free alternative to Smile.io?

Yes. As of 19 November 2026, LoyaltyLion offers a free plan up to 400 orders a month, Joy up to 250, Growave, Rivo and Smile.io up to 200, BON up to 150 and Yotpo for stores under 100 orders. Growave’s free plan also includes wishlist and product reviews.

Which Smile.io alternatives include VIP tiers, and from which plan?

On the App Store listings, Rivo includes VIP tiers on Scale from $49 a month (400 orders included, then $20 per 100). BON and Joy list them from $129. Smile.io, Growave and LoyaltyLion list them from $199. Okendo prices loyalty as a separate product and says Loyalty starts at $99 a month. Listed prices rise with order volume, so compare at your own volume.

Which Smile.io alternative includes reviews and wishlists?

Growave includes loyalty, wishlist and product reviews from its free plan. Okendo, Stamped and Yotpo are review platforms that sell loyalty as a separate subscription.

What is the difference between Smile.io and Growave?

Smile.io is a polished loyalty app with the Built for Shopify badge and a larger order allowance on Growth (2,500 against 1,500). Growave is a loyalty and retention platform with a POS Loyalty QR, loyalty events that fire into Klaviyo, and checkout extensions and a headless API from its $499 Plus plan. VIP tiers cost the same on both ($199 a month on Growth), and Growave’s plans also include reviews and wishlists.

Can I keep my points and tiers when I switch from Smile.io?

In most cases yes - ask the new vendor to import member balances, tiers and referral history before you cancel. Growave’s team handles the import. Run both programs briefly in parallel and tell members what changes.

How were the prices in this guide checked?

We read each plan, order limit and rating from the app’s Shopify App Store listing on 19 November 2026. Smile.io’s Plus and Enterprise plans come from smile.io/pricing. Stamped’s loyalty product isn’t listed on the App Store, so we don’t quote a price for it. Listed prices are starting points and rise with order volume, so we re-check them and update this page and its date.

No items found.

What is your current returning customer rate?

You're Below the Benchmark for Your Niche
The average returning customer rate for Growave merchants in the ${nicheLabel} category is ${benchmarkVal}%, and your current rate is below that.
You're Beating the Benchmark. Let's Take It Further
Great work, your returning customer rate is on par or above the average of ${benchmarkVal}% for Growave users in ${nicheLabel}.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Want to close the gap?

Our team can help identify what’s holding back your retention and implement proven strategies tailored to your niche.
Book a free retention audit
If you’re open to switching, we’ll buy out your existing loyalty contract and help push your numbers even further with personalized insights and automation.
Let’s talk retention growth
No items found.
Unlock retention secrets straight from our CEO
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Recommended Reads

Trusted by over 15000 brands running on Shopify

Rated 4.8 by 1,289 merchants
badge-built-for-shopify-share-54x54
Built for Shopify
★4.8Shopify
★4.7G2
★4.9Capterra
★4.9TrustRadius
★4.9GetApp
tracey hocking Growave
tracey hocking Growavelogo Lazybones
“Growave has been a game-changer for our Shopify store. For the price, Growave offers exceptional..."
Tracey Hocking
Creative Director of Lazybones
Jonathan Lee Growave
Jonathan Lee GrowaveLily Charmed Growave
”I have really enjoyed using the wishlist function, shoppable Instagram, and reviews. We love Growave because it brings real results. It helped us reduce the cart abandonment rate by 22%.”
Jonathan Lee
Director at Lily Charmed
Joshua Lloyd Growave
Joshua Lloyd Growave
”We were looking for some time to improve our loyalty program already in place and to improve our customer experience throughout the website. Growave was an excellent solution for that.”
Joshua Lloyd
CEO and Managing Director of Joshua Lloyd
Cate Burton Growave
Cate Burton GrowaveQueen B logo Growave
“My experience interacting with Growave has always been excellent. I haven't needed a huge amount from them. The app is pretty easy to install and I had no problem installing it myself.”
Cate Burton
CEO and Managing Director at Queen B