Wishlist Wizard vs. Yellos Wishlist: An In-Depth Comparison

Introduction

Choosing the right wishlist app is a surprisingly consequential decision for Shopify merchants. A wishlist can reduce friction, capture purchase intent, and feed other retention tactics like back-in-stock alerts, email flows, and social proof. But single-purpose wishlist apps vary widely in features, customization, localization, and long-term value. That makes selecting the right tool more than a checkbox — it affects conversion, repeat purchase behavior, and the number of apps a store ends up installing.

Short answer: Wishlist Wizard is a straightforward, no-frills wishlist tool that fits merchants who want a simple bookmark-style wishlist with a clear paid tiering for back-in-stock notifications. Yellos Wishlist aims to offer richer visual customization and multi-language support, which suits stores that need visual polish and global reach, but public evidence of real-world use and reviews is currently lacking. For merchants who want a single, integrated solution that combines wishlists with loyalty, referrals, and reviews to drive repeat purchases, an all-in-one retention platform provides better long-term value.

This post provides an in-depth, feature-by-feature comparison of Wishlist Wizard and Yellos Wishlist. The goal is to clarify each app’s strengths and limitations, show which store types each serves best, and then present an alternative approach that tackles the common problem of app fatigue and scattered feature sets.

Wishlist Wizard vs. Yellos Wishlist: At a Glance

Deep Dive Comparison

Feature Set Overview

Both apps focus on wishlist creation and customer convenience, but their feature priorities and visible ecosystem footprints differ.

Wishlist Wizard — Core Capabilities

Wishlist Wizard is presented as a classic bookmarking wishlist. The app emphasizes:

• Persistent wishlists synced across devices (Android, iPhone, desktop).
• Ability to share lists via email and social media.
• Two paid tiers: Standard ($15/month) and Pro ($20/month). The Pro plan adds back-in-stock notifications.
• Unlimited products and customers in both plans.

Strengths in the feature list center on straightforward functionality: merchants get unlimited catalogs and an option to add back-in-stock without complex configuration.

Yellos Wishlist — Core Capabilities

Yellos Wishlist markets itself as a more customizable, shopper-facing wishlist:

• Multiple wishlist creation and management.
• Theme matching via color, icon customization, and animations.
• Social sharing across popular platforms.
• Multi-language support for Arabic, Chinese, English, Hindi, Indonesian, and Spanish.

Yellos targets merchants that want visual parity with their storefront and support for diverse customer languages.

Granularity and Customization

Customization matters for UX: how closely a wishlist feels like part of the brand influences usage and conversion.

• Wishlist Wizard offers a utilitarian experience. The product description highlights mobile sync and sharing, but details about widget styling, button placement, and theme integration are sparse. Merchants seeking deep styling control may find it limited.
• Yellos Wishlist explicitly lists color, icon, and animation customization and the ability to create multiple wishlists, indicating a stronger emphasis on shopper-facing design. For stores with refined visual themes or multiple product categories that benefit from separate lists, this can be a differentiator.

Practical takeaway: stores prioritizing brand-consistent visuals and multiple list types will prefer Yellos; stores that want simple, fast implementation favor Wishlist Wizard.

Sharing and Social Features

Shoppable wishlists gain utility when they are easy to share and act upon.

• Wishlist Wizard supports sharing by email and social platforms, enabling customers to send lists to friends or save externally. The app describes sync features but does not elaborate on the social sharing formats (links, images, or embedded widgets).
• Yellos emphasizes shareability across “popular social media” and includes animations, which may make shared links more engaging on platforms like Facebook or Instagram. More visual sharing can improve click-through when a wishlist is promoted or referenced in social posts.

If social-driven buying or gift registries are a priority, Yellos’ visual sharing approach is more likely to appeal to marketing-led brands.

Multi-List and Multi-Language Support

• Wishlist Wizard’s public notes focus on a single wishlist per customer experience with cross-device sync. There is no explicit claim about multiple named lists or multi-language support.
• Yellos explicitly supports creating and managing multiple wishlists and lists multi-language support for at least six languages. For international stores or those selling across linguistic markets, built-in localization reduces friction and reliance on theme translations or additional apps.

Merchants operating international storefronts should consider Yellos for out-of-the-box language support.

Back-in-Stock and Inventory Signals

Back-in-stock alerts turn passive intent into recoverable revenue.

• Wishlist Wizard includes back-in-stock in its Pro plan ($20/month). That is an important upgrade path — wishlists become a retention signal that can trigger re-engagement.
• Yellos does not advertise back-in-stock functionality in the description provided. If a merchant depends on notifying customers automatically when out-of-stock items return, Wishlist Wizard’s Pro plan may be decisive.

Conclusion: for stores that want wishlists to feed inventory-triggered flows, Wishlist Wizard has a clear advantage.

Integrations and Ecosystem

Integration depth directly affects how well wishlist data can feed other marketing systems (email flows, SMS, loyalty programs).

• Wishlist Wizard’s public listing does not enumerate other platform integrations beyond device sync. The limited metadata suggests this app is primarily focused on wishlist mechanics rather than deep cross-app automation.
• Yellos also lacks an explicit integrations list in the available data. The emphasis is on the visual and management features rather than third-party connections.

Because integrations aren’t prominent for either app based on public listing data, merchants should assume limited native automation and plan for manual or custom approaches to pipe wishlist signals into email or loyalty systems unless documentation indicates otherwise.

Analytics & Reporting

Actionable wishlist analytics are rare in single-purpose apps but highly valuable. Merchants need to know which products are most wished for, how lists convert to purchases, and which customers are high-intent.

• Neither app lists robust analytics or dashboard features in the provided descriptions.
• Expect basic event capture (add to wishlist, remove, share) at best. For advanced analytics—cohorting users who saved items and later purchased—merchants may need to export data or use a third-party analytics service.

Merchants for whom wishlist analytics are strategic should verify reporting capabilities with developers before committing.

Performance, Stability & Scalability

Performance considerations vary by storefront size and traffic.

• Wishlist Wizard claims unlimited products and customers. That suggests the developer positions the app for catalogs of any size, at least in principle.
• Yellos does not list limits either, but custom animations and front-end widgets can add client-side performance overhead if not optimized.

Both apps require merchants to evaluate page load impact, especially if wishlists are visible on category pages or collection grids.

UI/UX and On-Store Experience

The quality of the on-store widget affects adoption.

• Wishlist Wizard focuses on ease of use and mobile sync. If the widget is reliable and unobtrusive, merchants can expect baseline adoption from shoppers.
• Yellos markets more polished visual options and animations, which can increase visibility and clicks if executed cleanly.

Merchants should request live demos or install in a trial environment to test how widgets behave on product pages, mobile breakpoints, and during cart flows.

Pricing & Value

Pricing is a critical decision factor when comparing single-purpose apps. Value-for-money depends on both feature set and how the app reduces friction that ultimately leads to revenue.

• Wishlist Wizard:
  • Standard Plan: $15 / month — Unlimited products/customers; no back-in-stock.
  • Pro Plan: $20 / month — Adds back-in-stock.
  • The pricing is straightforward and positioned as affordable for small-to-medium stores seeking a focused wishlist and a low-cost way to add inventory alerts.
• Yellos Wishlist:
  • Pricing is not publicly listed in the provided data. That lack of transparency requires merchants to contact the developer for a quote or to install to see a trial. Hidden pricing can be a barrier to fast decision-making.

Value assessment:

• Wishlist Wizard provides clear tiers and a tangible upgrade (back-in-stock) for a small incremental cost, which is attractive for stores that want a measurable feature to convert wishlist interest.
• Yellos may offer higher visual or multi-language value, but without pricing it is hard to quantify ROI. Merchants should request pricing and a feature matrix to compare total cost of ownership.

Avoiding surprises: if a merchant’s decision depends on low predictable costs, Wishlist Wizard’s published pricing is an advantage.

Support, Reviews & Trust Signals

Public reviews and developer responsiveness matter because apps touch customer data and storefront stability.

• Wishlist Wizard: Shopify listing shows 1 review with a 5-star rating. While positive, a single review is a small sample size and does not reliably signal long-term support quality.
• Yellos Wishlist: 0 reviews and a 0 rating. That makes it difficult to judge real-world merchant experiences.

When reviews are sparse, merchants should evaluate support channels, response times, and request references or case examples from the developer. A demo or trial installation combined with a short support test (e.g., ask a setup question and measure response) is a practical due-diligence step.

Compliance, Data Ownership & Privacy

Wishlists involve customer accounts and potentially email addresses or persistent identifiers.

• Neither app lists privacy compliance statements in the product description provided here. In practice, merchants should confirm:
  • GDPR and CCPA compliance practices.
  • How wishlist data is stored and whether it can be exported.
  • If the app uses third-party services for storage or analytics.

Data portability is essential; a wishlist should not trap user data in a black box.

Accessibility & Mobile Experience

Accessibility and mobile UX can affect conversion rates.

• Wishlist Wizard explicitly references mobile sync across Android and iPhone, which indicates attention to cross-device persistence.
• Yellos lists multi-language support and animations; animations must be implemented with accessibility in mind (turn-off options, reduced-motion support).

Merchants should evaluate both apps’ compliance with common accessibility guidelines and test on mobile devices.

Migration & Implementation Effort

Installing a wishlist app usually requires:

• Theme injection or adding a small widget.
• Possible CSS adjustments for consistent styling.
• Configuring share links and any notification settings.
• Wishlist Wizard likely offers quick installation with minimal configuration.
• Yellos’ customization options may require slightly more setup to match brand visuals and animation choices.

If a store uses a heavily customized theme, schedule time to test the widget in a staging environment.

Pros and Cons — Quick Summaries

Wishlist Wizard (Devsinc)

• Pros:
  • Clear, published pricing at $15–$20/month.
  • Back-in-stock functionality available on Pro plan.
  • Unlimited products/customers.
  • Simple, straightforward wishlist behavior and mobile sync.
• Cons:
  • Limited public reviews — only 1 review total.
  • Sparse public details on deep customization, analytics, or integrations.
  • May feel basic for merchants wanting polished visual options.

Yellos Wishlist (Evolution Infosystem Inc.)

• Pros:
  • Visual customization (colors, icons, animations).
  • Multiple wishlist management.
  • Multi-language support for six languages.
  • Emphasis on sharable, visually rich wishlist experiences.
• Cons:
  • No public pricing listed in the available data.
  • No public reviews — 0 reviews makes vetting harder.
  • No explicit back-in-stock or integrations mentioned.

Use Cases: Which App Suits Which Merchant?

These recommendations are framed around practical business outcomes like conversion, retention, and scalability.

• Best for merchants on a tight feature set and predictable monthly spend:
  • Wishlist Wizard is a solid choice for small-to-medium merchants who want a reliable wishlist with an inexpensive path to inventory alerts. The clear pricing makes budgeting straightforward.
• Best for merchants prioritizing design, multi-list workflows, or global customers:
  • Yellos Wishlist is better suited for stores that need multiple named lists, localized experiences, and brand-consistent visuals. It’s a fit for fashion, gifting, and lifestyle brands where the presentation of a wishlist is part of the marketing strategy.
• When to look beyond either app:
  • Stores that need analytics, integration with loyalty programs, centralized customer data, or a single unified retention stack should consider an all-in-one retention solution. Adding multiple single-purpose apps creates maintenance overhead and hidden costs.

The Alternative: Solving App Fatigue with an All-in-One Platform

Merchants often run into "app fatigue" as business needs expand. An entrepreneur starts with a wishlist app, later adds a reviews app, then a loyalty program, and finally a referral solution — each app requires installation, theme edits, separate billing, and fragmented customer data. That results in maintenance overhead, inconsistent customer experiences, and missed cross-channel opportunities.

The “More Growth, Less Stack” approach addresses these pain points by consolidating complementary retention features into one platform. Instead of managing five separate apps that each capture different behavior signals, a unified retention platform centralizes wishlists, loyalty programs, referrals, reviews, and VIP tiers. This reduces tool sprawl, simplifies integrations with email and support platforms, and creates cleaner data flows for automation.

Growave illustrates this approach by combining multiple retention tools into one suite:

• Merchants can build loyalty and rewards that drive repeat purchases, so wishlist activity can feed reward actions and point accrual.
• The platform lets stores collect and showcase authentic reviews, tying product wishlists to review reminders and UGC campaigns.
• A single solution simplifies on-site behavior tracking, enabling wishlists to trigger targeted emails, VIP invites, or referral offers.

Why consolidation matters:

• Data becomes actionable: When wishlist saves and referral sign-ups live in the same platform, automations can credit customers with points or trigger tailored campaigns without manual exports.
• Consistent UX: Widgets and customer-facing pages maintain the same styling and behavior, preserving brand experience across loyalty, review prompts, and wishlists.
• Cost predictability: One plan often replaces several per-app subscriptions and reduces the time cost of managing multiple vendors.

Practical examples of how consolidation pays off:

• A customer saves an out-of-stock coat to a wishlist. The platform uses that wishlist event to automatically enroll the customer in a back-in-stock notification, a loyalty reward for completing a purchase, and an email flow suggesting complementary items.
• A brand runs a seasonal referral campaign where existing customers earn points for successful referrals. Wishlists feed into segmentation so the brand can invite customers with high wishlist activity into VIP tiers with early access to product drops.

Growave’s product suite is purpose-built to reduce app bloat while increasing retention efficiency:

• The ability to build loyalty and rewards that drive repeat purchases ties directly into wishlist behavior, enabling merchants to reward intent.
• Merchants can collect and showcase authentic reviews tied to customers who convert from saved items, creating credible social proof around products shoppers already expressed interest in.
• For merchants evaluating an integrated option, it is possible to install a unified app from the Shopify App Store to replace multiple single-purpose installations and consolidate support into a single vendor relationship.

Cost and implementation advantages:

• Instead of paying separate subscriptions for wishlist, review, and loyalty apps, a consolidated platform provides predictable tiered pricing that covers a broader set of needs. Merchants can view pricing and plans to compare what a unified approach costs versus stacking several single-purpose tools.
• Centralized onboarding and a single support channel reduce the time-to-value for campaigns that require co-ordinated behavior, such as linking wishlist events to loyalty point triggers.

Hard CTA (optional): Book a personalized demo to see how an integrated retention stack improves retention.
Book a personalized demo to explore Growave’s unified approach.

How the All-in-One Approach Solves Specific Wishlist Limitations

• Back-in-stock as part of a broader lifecycle: Instead of a wishlisted item triggering only a single notification, an integrated platform turns that event into layered actions (notify customer, offer a small reward for purchasing, and use the purchase to invite the customer into a VIP tier).
• Cross-feature automation: Wishlist saves can increase a customer’s loyalty tier eligibility, which in turn affects shipping offers, exclusive access, and referral incentives — all automated inside one system.
• Unified reporting: A single analytics view shows how wishlists, reviews, and referral activity jointly affect LTV and repeat purchase rates.
• Fewer conflicts and less technical debt: One vendor managing widgets and scripts reduces the risk of theme conflicts and simplifies maintenance during Shopify updates.

Integration and Enterprise Considerations

Growing brands, especially those on Shopify Plus, need enterprise-grade features like API access, headless support, and dedicated onboarding. A unified platform often provides:

• Customizable loyalty rules and reward actions.
• API and SDK support for headless storefronts.
• Priority onboarding and customer success resources for launch planning.

Growave offers features tailored for scale, including capabilities suited for solutions for high-growth Plus brands. When growth velocity and technical complexity increase, a consolidated platform is easier to extend and support than a patchwork of narrowly focused apps.

Practical Comparison: Consolidation vs. Single-Purpose Choice

• If a merchant’s current priority is an affordable, simple wishlist with a known price and an incremental back-in-stock feature, Wishlist Wizard is a pragmatic short-term choice.
• If the immediate priority is visual customization and multi-language wishlist experiences, Yellos Wishlist may provide a better shopper-facing widget.
• If the priority is sustainable retention and reducing long-term tool complexity, switching to a single platform that consolidates wishlists with loyalty, reviews, and referrals delivers the most strategic value. Merchants can consolidate retention features and eliminate redundant app fees while gaining integrated reporting and automation.

Merchants considering consolidation should evaluate total cost of ownership, the operational overhead of multiple vendor relationships, and the upside of unified customer data.

Implementation Checklist for Merchants Evaluating Either App

Before installing any wishlist solution, use this checklist to reduce implementation surprises.

• Confirm the complete feature list and any undocumented limitations.
• Test installation on a staging theme to identify theme conflicts and page-weight impact.
• Verify data portability: ensure wishlist data can be exported or migrated.
• Ask the developer about GDPR/CCPA data handling, retention policies, and encryption.
• If localization matters, test the app in all storefront languages and ensure translations are accurate and context-sensitive.
• Request a support SLA or typical response time for setup and bug fixes.
• If loyalty or review workflows are required, confirm whether wishlist events can trigger external systems (via webhook or native integration) or whether a consolidated platform is a better fit.

Conclusion

For merchants choosing between Wishlist Wizard and Yellos Wishlist, the decision comes down to immediate priorities and long-term strategy. Wishlist Wizard provides a simple, clearly priced wishlist with an inexpensive upgrade path for back-in-stock notifications, making it a practical pick for stores seeking straightforward functionality and predictable monthly cost. Yellos Wishlist focuses on visual customization, multiple wishlist management, and multi-language support, which may appeal to brands that prioritize presentation and internationalization, though lack of public reviews and pricing visibility requires additional vetting.

For merchants looking beyond single-purpose tools and aiming to reduce app sprawl, an integrated retention platform offers stronger long-term value. Consolidating wishlists, loyalty, reviews, and referrals in one platform simplifies data flows, reduces maintenance overhead, and unlocks richer automations that directly improve retention and lifetime value. Merchants interested in that route can install a unified app or consolidate retention features and replace multiple subscriptions with a single integrated strategy.

Start a 14-day free trial to see how a unified retention stack improves repeat purchase rates.
Start a 14-day free trial

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main differences between Wishlist Wizard and Yellos Wishlist?
Wishlist Wizard emphasizes a simple wishlist with clear pricing and a Pro upgrade that adds back-in-stock alerts. Yellos Wishlist focuses on visual customization, multiple wishlist management, and multi-language support. Wishlist Wizard’s transparency in pricing is an advantage for budget-conscious merchants; Yellos’ feature set suits merchants who prioritize design and localization, though pricing and user reviews are not publicly available.

Which app is better for international stores?
Yellos Wishlist explicitly lists multi-language support for languages like Arabic, Chinese, Spanish, and others, making it the more obvious choice for international storefronts. Wishlist Wizard does not advertise localized interfaces in the provided data, so international merchants should verify localization capabilities before choosing it.

How does an all-in-one platform compare to specialized wishlist apps?
An all-in-one platform consolidates wishlists, loyalty, referrals, and reviews into a single ecosystem. That reduces tool sprawl, improves data flow for automations (e.g., using wishlist saves to trigger loyalty rewards), simplifies billing and support, and often produces better long-term ROI. Specialized apps can be cheaper or faster to implement for a single feature, but they increase maintenance overhead and limit cross-feature automations.

Can wishlist activity be used to drive loyalty and referrals?
Yes. Wishlist signals indicate purchase intent. In a consolidated platform environment, wishlist saves can be mapped to loyalty reward actions, segmentation for referral campaigns, and targeted email flows. Without integration, merchants must manually export data or use custom development to connect wishlist events to other systems; a unified solution streamlines this process and reduces time-to-value.