Ultimate Wishlist vs. Wizy Wishlist: An In-Depth Comparison

Introduction

Choosing the right wishlist app is a deceptively important decision for Shopify merchants. A wishlist can increase conversions, surface product demand, and keep customers coming back — but the wrong tool can add technical debt, fragment analytics, and create extra monthly costs. This comparison examines two single-purpose wishlist apps — Ultimate Wishlist (Config Studio) and Wizy Wishlist (PATH) — to help merchants pick the right tool for their needs.

Short answer: Ultimate Wishlist is a strong choice for stores that want a lightweight, highly rated wishlist with flexible guest and account-based options, plus useful analytics on a low-cost tier. Wizy Wishlist offers straightforward wishlist functionality with tiered capacity for higher-volume stores, but it lacks public reviews and social proof. For merchants who want to reduce tool sprawl and combine wishlist capabilities with loyalty, referrals, and reviews, an integrated retention platform like Growave can provide better long-term value.

This post provides an in-depth, feature-by-feature comparison of Ultimate Wishlist and Wizy Wishlist. It evaluates core functionality, customization, pricing and value, integrations, analytics, performance, and support. After the direct comparison, the article explains the trade-offs of single-purpose apps and presents an all-in-one alternative that addresses those limits.

Ultimate Wishlist vs. Wizy Wishlist: At a Glance

Feature-by-Feature Comparison

Core Wishlist Functionality

Both apps deliver the basic wishlist capability: let customers save products for later. However, how they implement that capability affects retention, conversion tracking, and customer experience.

Ultimate Wishlist

• Allows customers to create wishlists with or without registration. This flexibility reduces friction for first-time visitors and still supports logged-in cross-device sync for repeat buyers.
• Offers sharing via Facebook, Twitter, and email. Social sharing can drive referral traffic and product visibility.
• Includes customizable email templates and reminder sending (limited by plan caps).
• Includes a dashboard that tracks wishlist adds, page views, and adds-to-cart — useful signals for merchandising.

Wizy Wishlist

• Offers pop-up or dedicated wishlist page modes, allowing stores to choose between an inline experience or a modal interaction.
• Supports both guest and member interactions (store says "whether members or not") but provides fewer details about cross-device persistence.
• Focuses on easy access to saved items and quick move-to-cart flows.
• Includes an admin panel with statistics to track demand.

Head-to-head practical impact

• Ultimate Wishlist’s explicit mention of logged-in sync gives it an advantage where cross-device persistence is important (e.g., shoppers researching on mobile, buying on desktop).
• Wizy’s pop-up mode can be less intrusive and faster to interact with for stores prioritizing speed and minimal UI changes.
• For stores that rely on follow-up email reminders to convert saved lists into purchases, Ultimate Wishlist provides built-in templating and tiered reminder sending that makes lifecycle re-engagement more straightforward.

Guest vs. Account-Based Wishlist

Guest wishlists reduce friction, but they also reduce the ability to tie wishlist activity to a customer record.

Ultimate Wishlist

• Supports both guest and account-based wishlists. Guest lists are useful for high funnel conversions; logged-in lists support cross-device syncing and better segmentation within marketing automation.

Wizy Wishlist

• Allows customers to add items whether or not they are members, but public documentation is less explicit about cross-device persistence and how guest lists are preserved or migrated to accounts.

Practical recommendation

• Merchants who run email remarketing or want to attribute wishlist behavior to known customers should favor a solution that clearly supports account-bound lists with robust syncing. Ultimate Wishlist is more explicit on that point.

Add-to-Cart and Checkout Flow

A wishlist’s usefulness is tied to how easily items move from the wishlist to checkout.

Ultimate Wishlist

• Tracks "added to cart" conversions in its dashboard, indicating a bridge between wishlist and purchase behavior.
• Email reminders can include direct product links to facilitate rapid conversion.

Wizy Wishlist

• Emphasizes the ability to "instantly purchase items from the Wishlist" and speed up the shopping process. The app aims for fast list-to-cart interactions but provides fewer details about commerce tracking.

Practical recommendation

• If measuring the impact of wishlist activity on conversions is critical, an app that surfaces add-to-cart metrics in the admin is valuable. Ultimate Wishlist provides those metrics transparently.

Sharing and Social Behavior

Sharing drives discovery and can amplify product demand.

Ultimate Wishlist

• Explicit sharing via Facebook, Twitter, and Email increases visibility for saved items and can act as a low-cost acquisition channel for social stores.

Wizy Wishlist

• Does not emphasize social sharing beyond internal wishlist access. The focus is usability rather than distribution.

Practical recommendation

• Stores that rely on social channels or user-driven product discovery will benefit from built-in sharing options.

Customization & Design

Visual consistency with the storefront is important to prevent wishlist UI from feeling tacked-on.

Ultimate Wishlist

• Highlights full customization: text, colors, and non-English support. That makes it a good fit for branded stores and international merchants needing multi-language text tweaks.
• Menu placement and wishlist appearance can be tailored to match the store.

Wizy Wishlist

• Also promotes customization and lets merchants choose between pop-up or page modes. It focuses on simple UI choices rather than deep theme-level styling.

Practical recommendation

• For merchants with strict brand guidelines or multi-language stores, Ultimate Wishlist’s explicit non-English support and detailed customization will provide better alignment.

Email Reminders & Lifecycle Marketing

Built-in reminder emails can convert saved interest into purchases without additional marketing tools.

Ultimate Wishlist

• Offers a customizable email template and different reminder capacities across plans (e.g., Basic: up to 500 reminders/month; Pro: up to 2,000; Premium up to 5,000).
• Pro and Premium tiers add ability to send reminders to individual users and include Facebook pixel integration for retargeting.

Wizy Wishlist

• Does not advertise a built-in reminder engine. The app’s conversion path appears to depend on in-store interactions rather than automated email re-engagement.

Practical recommendation

• Stores that need an out-of-the-box reminder cadence and simple email templates will get more immediate value from Ultimate Wishlist. Those already using an email platform like Klaviyo can replicate reminders externally, but that adds complexity.

Analytics & Reporting

Knowing which items are being saved and how wishlist activity correlates to purchases informs merchandising and inventory decisions.

Ultimate Wishlist

• Markets a "powerful dashboard" with analytics of wishlist add events, page views, and adds-to-cart. This provides clear signals merchants can action.
• Premium plan includes Facebook pixel integration for ad tracking and retargeting.

Wizy Wishlist

• Provides a control panel with "powerful statistics" per its description, but public-facing detail is sparse and there are no visible social-proof review counts to verify adoption.

Practical recommendation

• Ultimate Wishlist’s transparent analytics and pixel integration make it easier to measure downstream ad effectiveness and merchandising impact.

Integrations & Ecosystem

A wishlist rarely functions in isolation; integration with the rest of the stack matters for data portability and automation.

Ultimate Wishlist

• Explicitly lists Facebook pixel integration on Premium. Its feature set suggests compatibility with common flows (email reminders, sharing links).
• Config Studio’s documentation and support presence imply a modest integration footprint.

Wizy Wishlist

• Focused on core wishlist and in-store behavior. No detailed public integration list is provided.

Practical recommendation

• Merchants who require pixel-level event firing for ad platforms or who want to push wishlist data into external tools will find Ultimate Wishlist more transparent. For deeper, multi-channel automation, consider a platform that advertises native integrations.

Pricing & Value

Price is important, but the right metric is value for money — how much business outcome an app drives relative to its cost.

Ultimate Wishlist

• Free tier: supports up to 500 wishlist items/month, guest lists, collection-page placement, sharing, customizable text/colors, non-English support, and reports.
• Basic: $4.99/month — raises capacity to 1,000 items/month, adds custom email templates and up to 500 email reminders/month.
• Pro: $9.99/month — up to 5,000 items, individualized reminders, 2,000 reminders/month.
• Premium: $14.99/month — up to 10,000 items, 5,000 reminders/month, Facebook pixel integration.

Wizy Wishlist

• Standard: $4.99/month — pop-up/page wishlist, 500 wishlists.
• Pro: $9.99/month — 1,000 wishlists.
• Advanced: $39.99/month — 5,000 wishlists.
• Enterprise: $79.99/month — 10,000 wishlists.

Value assessment

• Ultimate Wishlist’s free tier is a notable advantage for very small stores or merchants evaluating wishlists before committing.
• Wizy’s pricing starts at $4.99 and scales up to $79.99 for enterprise capacity. The pricing jump from $9.99 to $39.99 is significant and may not align with all merchant budgets.
• Ultimate Wishlist includes email reminders and pixel integration on higher tiers at comparatively modest prices, which can drive measurable revenue without adding extra apps.
• Wizy may be suitable for stores willing to pay more for higher capacity but less intent on email-based re-engagement.

Recommendation on pricing

• For merchants who want a low-cost start and built-in reminder capabilities, Ultimate Wishlist offers better value for money.
• For stores that only need a high-capacity wishlist without email reminders, Wizy covers capacity needs but at higher price points for the top tiers.

Support & Social Proof

Support responsiveness and app marketplace reviews are proxies for reliability and ongoing development.

Ultimate Wishlist

• 34 reviews with a 4.9 rating on the Shopify App Store. That level of social proof suggests a satisfied user base for the app’s core functionality.

Wizy Wishlist

• 0 reviews and a 0 rating publicly. The absence of reviews can indicate a newer app, lower adoption, or limited visibility — all of which make it harder for merchants to assess long-term reliability.

Practical recommendation

• The review count and high rating for Ultimate Wishlist provide confidence for merchants who value community feedback. Wizy’s lack of visible reviews requires merchants to rely on direct trial and support inquiries.

Implementation, Performance & Code Footprint

Every app adds script weight and potential performance impact. Small differences in implementation affect page load and storefront stability.

Ultimate Wishlist

• Designed as a lightweight wishlist; specific implementation details vary by theme. The availability of pop-up or page options suggests flexibility to balance UX and performance.
• Premium’s pixel integration indicates event-based scripts that should be monitored for load impact.

Wizy Wishlist

• Offers pop-up mode which can be a lighter-weight UI depending on implementation, but specifics about script loading and asynchronous behavior are not clear in public docs.

Practical recommendation

• Performance-conscious merchants should test both apps in a staging environment and use Lighthouse/web vitals to compare script impact. Look for asynchronous loading and minimal DOM manipulation.

Security, Privacy & Data Handling

Wishlist data can include personal identifiers when tied to accounts or emails; compliance and data portability matter.

Ultimate Wishlist

• Supports account-based lists and email reminders; merchants should confirm data export, retention policies, and GDPR compliance directly with the developer. Facebook pixel integration increases the need for proper consent banners.

Wizy Wishlist

• Offers data tracking and a control panel; merchants should verify how guest lists are handled, whether user data is stored externally, and how to comply with GDPR/CCPA.

Practical recommendation

• For merchants in regulated regions, obtaining written confirmation on data handling and export is essential before deploying reminder emails or pixel-based retargeting.

Use Cases & Merchant Recommendations

• Merchants on a tight budget, testing wishlist mechanics, or wanting built-in reminders: Ultimate Wishlist (Free → $14.99) provides a clear pathway from trial to modest scale with reminders and analytics.
• Brands that want a simple, minimal wishlist modal or page with clear capacity tiers and are less concerned about reminders or social sharing: Wizy Wishlist can work, but the lack of public reviews requires caution.
• Stores that plan to grow and also want loyalty, referrals, and reviews alongside wishlist functionality should consider an integrated platform to avoid stacking multiple single-purpose apps.

Implementation Checklist: What to Test Before Installing

Before committing to either app, consider validating these items:

• Theme compatibility: Test install in a development theme and confirm wishlist buttons or pop-ups match brand styling.
• Cross-device persistence: Add items on mobile and verify logged-in accounts see the same wishlist on desktop.
• Add-to-cart flow: Confirm how items transfer to cart and whether variant selection is preserved.
• Email flow (Ultimate Wishlist): Review reminder templates, test deliverability, and check if emails pass spam filters.
• Analytics: Confirm that wishlist events appear in analytics and that pixel events fire correctly.
• Performance: Measure page load before and after install using web vitals.
• Data export: Verify how to export wishlist data and how long guest lists are retained.
• Support responsiveness: Submit a pre-sale or technical question to evaluate response time.

Pricing Comparison Table (Quick Reference)

Support & Reviews: Interpreting the Numbers

App marketplace review counts are imperfect but useful signals.

• Ultimate Wishlist: 34 reviews, average 4.9/5 — suggests positive experiences and active user base. Merchants can read reviews to learn about common issues, implementation tips, and developer responsiveness.
• Wizy Wishlist: 0 reviews — absence of reviews increases uncertainty. Merchants should rely on test installs and direct developer contact to assess reliability.

The Alternative: Solving App Fatigue with an All-in-One Platform

A growing concern for merchants is "app fatigue" — the accumulation of single-purpose apps that each add cost, require separate configuration, and fragment customer data across vendors. Single-function wishlist apps solve immediate problems but often introduce trade-offs:

• Multiple billing lines and administrative overhead.
• Fragmented analytics — wishlist behavior sits in one dashboard, loyalty activity in another, and reviews in a third, making holistic customer lifetime value harder to measure.
• Increased risk of script collisions and performance degradation as each vendor injects code.
• Higher long-term cost if desired features (reminders, loyalty, referrals, reviews) require additional apps.

The alternative is an integrated retention platform that combines wishlist functionality with loyalty, referrals, reviews, and VIP tiers. This approach reduces tool sprawl and centralizes customer engagement.

Growave’s approach follows a "More Growth, Less Stack" philosophy. By consolidating core retention tools into a single suite, merchants can reduce monthly overhead, unify analytics, and launch coordinated campaigns (e.g., reward points for wishlist actions, automated review requests after wishlist conversions).

Why consolidation matters

• Centralized data makes it easier to identify high-value customers and design rewards that increase repeat purchases.
• Integrated automation removes the need to manually sync wishlist activity to external tools for remarketing.
• A single integration reduces the chances of theme conflicts and script-related performance issues.

Growave offers a combined suite that includes Loyalty & Rewards, Referrals, Reviews & UGC, Wishlist, and VIP Tiers. Merchants can explore different pricing plans to match store size and growth needs; for a clear view of plan options and what’s included, merchants can consolidate retention features. The Growave app is also available to install directly from the Shopify ecosystem, which simplifies onboarding and verification for Shopify merchants who prefer to work through the official app listing: install Growave from the Shopify App Store.

How Growave Bridges the Functional Gaps Found in Single-Feature Apps

• Wishlist + Lifecycle Marketing: The wishlist is not an isolated component — Growave ties wishlist actions to the loyalty engine so merchants can reward saves or purchases originating from wishlists. This creates more pathways to retention than a standalone wishlist that only emails reminders.
• Reviews & UGC: Growave allows merchants to request and collect reviews tied to customer journeys. That means wishlist conversions can later be encouraged to leave reviews, which amplifies social proof. Merchants can see how wishlist interactions translate to authentic testimonials by using tools to collect and showcase authentic reviews.
• Loyalty & Rewards: Reward points, VIP tiers, and referral incentives can be combined with wishlist events to create compelling loops that boost lifetime value. Merchants can build loyalty and rewards that drive repeat purchases.
• Integrations & Scale: Growave supports enterprise requirements and integrates with platforms like Klaviyo, Omnisend, Recharge, and helpdesk solutions, enabling automation that single-purpose apps struggle to do without custom engineering.

Practical Outcomes of Consolidation

• Reduced tool maintenance and fewer updates to manage across multiple vendors.
• Centralized reporting that links wishlist saves, referral conversions, review acquisition, and loyalty-driven repeat purchases.
• Fewer monthly fees for apps that deliver duplicated value; overall return on investment improves when features are used in tandem.

Where an All-in-One May Not Be the Right Choice

Consolidation is not always the answer. Some merchants have strict architectural or procurement requirements that demand piecemeal solutions. Others prefer best-of-breed tools that specialize deeply in one function and integrate across systems. For those scenarios, a single-purpose wishlist may still be the right short-term choice.

However, for most merchants seeking to scale retention and minimize stack complexity, a unified platform provides demonstrable operational and strategic benefits.

For merchants evaluating consolidation, it’s helpful to review plans and compare costs versus cumulative spend of multiple single-purpose apps. For a side-by-side cost comparison and to learn what’s included at each level, merchants can consolidate retention features. Those considering enterprise-level retention solutions will find dedicated resources that explain capabilities for larger stores and headless setups in the Growave Plus documentation; merchants can read how Growave supports solutions for high-growth Plus brands.

Migration & Exit Considerations

If switching from a single-purpose wishlist to a combined platform, consider these steps:

• Export wishlist data: Ensure the current app supports data export (customer email, product handles, timestamps).
• Map data fields: Align wishlist fields to the new platform’s data model.
• Plan communications: Notify customers if wishlist behavior will change or if data will be migrated for marketing use.
• Test conversions: Run A/B tests to compare conversion lift from the old approach versus the unified stack.
• Decommission old apps: Remove redundant apps to prevent duplicated event firing or script clashes.

Growave provides onboarding assistance for merchants moving from multiple apps. For merchants who prefer a live walkthrough before migrating, there is an option to book a demo with product experts.

Comparing Long-Term Business Impact

When assessing which route to take, focus on outcomes rather than features alone:

• Retention: A wishlist that ties into loyalty programs will increase repeat purchase probability more reliably than a wishlist that only reminds via email.
• Lifetime Value: Programs that combine referrals, rewards, and VIP tiers can increase average order frequency and size, improving LTV.
• Operational Efficiency: One dashboard reduces the time needed to manage promotions, create reports, and troubleshoot problems.

Merchants can model potential gains from consolidation by mapping expected increases in repeat purchase rate and average order value against subscription costs. When combined features drive measurable lift, the per-month price of an integrated solution often yields better ROI than multiple single-purpose subscriptions.

Practical Next Steps for Merchants

• If a merchant’s immediate objective is to trial wishlist behavior with minimal cost and they need email reminders, Ultimate Wishlist’s free tier and low-cost plans are a practical starting point.
• If the primary need is a simple wishlist UI that scales capacity and the merchant has an established lifecycle stack already, Wizy might suffice — but insist on a test install to verify performance and data handling.
• If the growth plan includes loyalty, referrals, reviews, and centralized analytics, evaluate consolidation with Growave to reduce stack complexity and unlock multi-channel retention tactics. For pricing transparency and feature comparisons, merchants can consolidate retention features and review the app listing to confirm compatibility: install Growave from the Shopify App Store.

Conclusion

For merchants choosing between Ultimate Wishlist and Wizy Wishlist, the decision comes down to specific needs and priorities. Ultimate Wishlist (Config Studio) wins on social proof, a free onboarding tier, built-in email reminders, and pixel integration at accessible price points — making it a strong option for stores that want immediate conversion-focused wishlist capabilities and analytics. Wizy Wishlist (PATH) provides straightforward wishlist UI choices and capacity scaling, but the lack of public reviews and limited visibility into advanced features increases the evaluation burden for merchants.

Beyond single-purpose apps, many merchants face the strategic cost of app fatigue: multiple subscriptions, fragmented data, and duplicated effort. An integrated retention platform that bundles wishlist with loyalty, referrals, reviews, and VIP tiers can reduce that burden and deliver better lifetime value. For merchants ready to consolidate retention tools and accelerate growth with a single platform, consider exploring Growave’s plans and capabilities to compare total cost and outcomes. Merchants can consolidate retention features or view the app in the Shopify ecosystem to confirm requirements: install Growave from the Shopify App Store. To see how a unified retention stack affects retention and LTV, consolidate retention features and review feature tiers in detail.

Start a 14-day free trial to see how a unified retention stack accelerates growth. Start a 14-day free trial

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: How do the wishlist features of Ultimate Wishlist and Wizy Wishlist differ in a way that affects conversions?

• Ultimate Wishlist includes built-in email reminders and add-to-cart tracking, which provides a direct mechanism to convert saved items into purchases and measure that impact. Wizy focuses on fast wishlist UX and capacity scaling but does not advertise a built-in reminder engine, so conversions may rely on other tools or organic revisit behavior.

Q: Which app is better for international or multi-language stores?

• Ultimate Wishlist explicitly supports non-English customization, making it more suitable for multi-language stores that need translated wishlist UI and texts. Wizy does not emphasize non-English support in its public description.

Q: If a store already uses Klaviyo or Omnisend, does that change the recommendation?

• Stores already invested in email platforms can replicate reminder flows externally, but that adds complexity and requires syncing wishlist events. Ultimate Wishlist’s native reminders reduce setup time. For deeper automation and unified reporting, an integrated platform that provides native integrations with Klaviyo and Omnisend will simplify operations.

Q: How does an all-in-one platform compare to specialized apps?

• An all-in-one platform consolidates wishlist, loyalty, referrals, and reviews into a single suite, which reduces administrative overhead, centralizes customer data, and enables coordinated campaigns that single-purpose apps cannot execute without additional integrations. Consolidation often results in better long-term ROI when the features are actively used together. Merchants can compare plans and feature sets to decide whether consolidation or a best-of-breed approach fits the business model.

Q: What are the migration considerations if moving from a single wishlist app to an integrated platform?

• Key steps include exporting wishlist data, mapping fields to the new platform, validating emails and pixel implementations, testing add-to-cart flows, and decommissioning old apps to prevent duplicate event firing. For assistance with migration planning, merchants can book a demo with product experts.