SWishlist: Simple Wishlist vs. K Wish List‑Advanced Wishlist: An In-Depth Comparison

Introduction

Selecting the right wishlist solution is a surprisingly important choice for Shopify merchants. Wishlists can reduce cart friction, surface high-intent products, and provide data that informs merchandising and marketing. But choosing between compact, single-purpose tools and more feature-rich alternatives requires careful trade-offs.

Short answer: SWishlist: Simple Wishlist is an excellent choice for merchants who want an easy-to-install, lightweight wishlist with an outstanding user rating and low monthly cost. K Wish List‑Advanced Wishlist is better suited for stores that need flexible on-page display options, social sharing, and a variety of UI placements (floating button, header icon, popup, embedded). For merchants who want to consolidate multiple retention tools into one platform and avoid tool sprawl, Growave presents a higher-value alternative.

This article provides a feature-by-feature, practical comparison of SWishlist: Simple Wishlist (SoluCommerce) and K Wish List‑Advanced Wishlist (Kaktus). The goal is to help merchants evaluate both options objectively—covering core functionality, setup experience, pricing and value, integrations, reporting, and recommended use cases—before introducing a unified alternative for brands that need more than a single-purpose wishlist.

SWishlist: Simple Wishlist vs. K Wish List‑Advanced Wishlist: At a Glance

How the comparison is organized

The next sections examine key decision factors merchants use when evaluating wishlist apps: features and UX, setup and customizability, pricing and value, integrations and extensibility, reporting and analytics, support and reliability, and common merchant use cases. Each section highlights strengths, limitations, and practical guidance about which app fits which merchant profile.

Feature Comparison

Core Wishlist Functionality

SWishlist: Simple Wishlist

SWishlist centers on making wishlisting frictionless. The core components are an add-to-wishlist button, a shareable wishlist page, and customization options to match the store's look and feel. The app emphasizes simple, reliable saving and sharing, and provides multi-language storefront support depending on plan level.

Strengths:

• High rating (4.9) across 106 reviews indicates strong user satisfaction.
• Clear focus on the essential wishlist user journeys: save, share, revisit.
• Multi-language support at higher tiers (up to 20 languages on Premium).
• Free plan supports up to 300 wishlist additions per month, which is useful for small stores.

Limitations:

• Free and Basic tiers impose caps on monthly wishlist additions (300 and 7,000 respectively). Stores with high traffic or heavy promotional periods may hit limits.
• Feature set focuses on wishlist functionality only—no built-in loyalty or review features.
• Integrations beyond API usage are not emphasized.

K Wish List‑Advanced Wishlist

K Wish List aims to be flexible about how wishlists are presented. It supports a floating button, a header icon, embedded wishlist pages, and popups. Social media sharing and configurable labels/icons are standard, designed to increase product saves and gift-list creation.

Strengths:

• Multiple UI placements let merchants choose how prominently to surface the wishlist (float, header, popup, embedded).
• Social sharing is emphasized—helpful for gift shopping and events.
• Free plan includes core display options, which can be enough for many stores.
• Setup is marketed as no-code, appealing for merchants without developer resources.

Limitations:

• Slightly lower rating (4.7) across fewer reviews (81), which still indicates solid satisfaction but less social proof than SWishlist.
• Feature differentiation leans toward presentation rather than advanced behavioral or retention hooks.
• Less explicit multi-language support details in the provided listing.

Wishlist Display, Customization, and UX

Visual Placement and On-Page UX

SWishlist provides standard wishlist button and page options with theme integration and customization to match branding. It allows sharing and appears to support storefront language configuration.

K Wish List offers more presentation choices out of the box—floating action button, header icon, popup, embedded pages—which can be useful to A/B test placement and determine what drives the most saves for a particular catalog and theme.

Practical takeaway: If control over how the wishlist appears on product listings and throughout the site is critical, K Wish List provides more display presets. If a consistent brand-matching wishlist with good localization and simple flows is fine, SWishlist is adequate and slightly more polished based on user ratings.

Customization and Theming

SWishlist highlights the ability to “customize everything to perfectly match your store.” That generally means labels, icons, colors, and theme-aware installation. The Premium plan expands storefront language coverage to 20 languages, which helps multi-regional stores.

K Wish List explicitly calls out customizable icons, labels, and colors, plus the ability to show wishlist as a dedicated page or popup. The no-code setup suggests merchants can make these changes without developer time.

Practical takeaway: Both apps support design customization; the difference is that K Wish List emphasizes layout versatility while SWishlist emphasizes localization and support responsiveness.

Sharing and Social Features

Both apps support wishlist sharing, which is crucial for gift-centric purchases and social proof.

SWishlist supports sharing wishlists with friends; the store page implies straightforward sharing flows.

K Wish List puts social sharing front and center: share wishlist via social channels and marketing. That can add a referral-like lift for product discovery.

Practical takeaway: For stores running gift campaigns or relying on social referrals, K Wish List’s sharing features and floating CTA may generate more immediate social visibility. SWishlist’s sharing is solid but framed within a simpler, focused UX.

Customer Accounts and Persistence

Persistence and how wishlists attach to customer accounts matter for long-term retention.

SWishlist’s description emphasizes personalized wishlists and provides storefront language options and statistics at higher tiers. The app works via API, which suggests the potential to integrate wishlist data with CRM or email tools if the merchant invests in custom work.

K Wish List’s notes about “Customers Wishlists” indicate support for logged-in users saving and retrieving their lists. Kaktus also mentions tracking wishlist usage for merchant insights.

Practical takeaway: Both apps allow customer-specific wishlist persistence. If a store plans to tie wishlist activity directly into marketing automation (e.g., email reminders or abandoned wishlist flows), SWishlist may require API work while K Wish List’s checkout compatibility could be simpler for common workflows.

Setup, Installation, and Onboarding

Installation Complexity

SWishlist promotes “free setup up to 2 themes per store” on the Free plan and claims priority support on higher tiers. The setup likely involves theme script injection and configuration in the app dashboard. The availability of free setup indicates lower friction for small merchants.

K Wish List’s claim of “set up in minutes with no coding required” suggests minimal technical overhead: install the app, configure display style, and toggle the wishlist in relevant places.

Practical takeaway: Both apps are accessible for non-technical merchants. K Wish List’s emphasis on no-code setup may be more inviting for merchants without developer support. SWishlist's free setup support is a valuable safety net for stores with complex themes.

Time to Value

K Wish List’s multiple placement options allow merchants to surface the wishlist quickly and test performance in days. SWishlist’s setup with included theme support on the free tier gives similar time-to-value with the added benefit of support response SLAs that improve on paid plans.

Practical takeaway: Expect either app to deliver value quickly—K Wish List through rapid UI toggles and SWishlist via guided theme setup and multi-language readiness.

Pricing and Value

Pricing is a frequent deciding factor. Instead of focusing solely on sticker price, evaluate limits, SLA, and overall value delivered.

SWishlist Pricing Overview

• Free: 300 wishlist additions/month, 2 languages on storefront, free setup up to 2 themes, support within 24–48 hours.
• Basic ($5/month): 7,000 wishlist additions/month, 7 languages, all Free plan features, support in 12–24 hours.
• Premium ($12/month): Unlimited wishlist additions, 20 languages, unlimited statistics access, top-priority support.

Value considerations:

• Clear free tier for testing is useful for small stores.
• $5/month Basic gives a large jump in quota (7,000 additions) and expanded language support—strong value for low-cost merchants.
• $12/month Premium removes add-limit friction and adds analytics—good for growing stores that need unlimited saves and reporting.

K Wish List Pricing Overview

• FREE: Includes float button, header icon, add-to-wishlist, notifications, social sharing, popup & embedded options, customer wishlists, support.
• Growth ($6.70/month): Appears to match free features; pricing suggests scaling support or usage-based allowances.
• Growth 2 ($19.99/month): Same feature list as Growth but presumably aimed at higher volumes or merchants needing prioritized support.

Value considerations:

• Generous free feature set is attractive; most core UI options are available without monthly fees.
• Paid tiers' differentiation is less explicit in the listing; stores should confirm limits and support SLAs before upgrading.
• Price points are reasonable but reach $19.99 for higher tiers, which is still affordable relative to many specialized apps.

Value-for-Money Comparison

Both apps offer strong entry-level value. SWishlist’s tiered addition limits and clear upgrade path make it straightforward to forecast costs as wishlist usage grows. K Wish List’s free feature breadth is compelling, but merchants should validate any hidden volume caps or branding limitations.

Instead of choosing strictly on price, merchants should evaluate expected monthly wishlist actions, desired localization needs, and whether analytics or developer integrations are required. For merchants seeking a single wishlist plug-in without additional retention features, either option offers good value for money; SWishlist edges ahead for stores that expect high volumes and need a transparent unlimited plan for $12/month.

Integrations and Extensibility

API and Checkout Compatibility

SWishlist: Works with API. That indicates the app can be extended programmatically and tied into external systems (CRM, email platforms) if the merchant has development resources.

K Wish List: Works with Checkout. This suggests easier compatibility with store checkout flows and possibly checkout UI placements. For merchants who want wishlist data connected to checkout or saved in customer records without heavy custom work, checkout compatibility helps.

Practical takeaway: Choose SWishlist when custom integrations are planned and a developer can leverage the API; choose K Wish List when checkout-level compatibility and fast, no-code connections matter more.

Marketing and CRM Integrations

Neither app advertises a broad native integration catalog in the provided data. Merchants who rely heavily on Klaviyo, Omnisend, or other email platforms should verify whether wishlist events can be forwarded or connected to their marketing system. SWishlist’s API orientation can enable such connections with development support. K Wish List’s checkout compatibility may allow for easier event capture without custom code, but merchants should confirm support for their email provider.

Extensibility for Advanced Use

For merchants planning complex flows—like rewarding wishlist saves, triggering segmented campaigns when wishlist items go on sale, or enriching user profiles—single-purpose apps reach natural limits. At that point, evaluate platforms that combine wishlist with loyalty and referral features to avoid building integrations between multiple vendors.

Reporting, Data, and Merchant Insights

What Each App Offers

SWishlist: Premium plan includes “unlimited access to all statistics.” That implies on-dashboard reporting of wishlist actions, most-saved items, and possibly user-level data. The presence of an API also allows exporting data for deeper analysis.

K Wish List: Mentions “Track wishlist usage to gain insights into customer interest,” which suggests built-in usage metrics but may not be as detailed as SWishlist’s Premium analytics offering.

Practical takeaway: Merchants who value richer, continuous analytics should consider SWishlist’s Premium tier. K Wish List provides useful usage tracking, especially for understanding which placements drive saves, but merchants needing exportable, actionable datasets should verify the depth of the reports.

Data Portability

Both apps should be evaluated on data export capabilities and retention. If a merchant plans to switch apps later, the ability to export wishlist records and customer associations is critical. SWishlist’s API approach typically supports exports. Merchants should ask Kaktus about export formats and retention policies.

Support, Reliability, and Reputation

Ratings and Review Volume

• SWishlist: 106 reviews, 4.9 rating. That is strong social proof—high average satisfaction and a decent sample size for an app of this type.
• K Wish List: 81 reviews, 4.7 rating. Also solid feedback but fewer reviews and a slightly lower average.

Practical takeaway: SWishlist’s combination of higher rating and more reviews suggests merchants frequently find it reliable and effective. K Wish List has positive reviews but slightly less validation at scale.

Support SLAs and Responsiveness

SWishlist clearly states support response windows per plan:

• Free: 24–48 hours
• Basic: 12–24 hours
• Premium: top priority

K Wish List describes “knowledgeable support” but does not detail response windows in the listing. Merchants who require predictable response times (e.g., during a flash sale) may prefer SWishlist’s explicit SLA tiers.

Reliability & Performance

Both apps that modify storefront behavior must be evaluated for page performance impact. Merchants should:

• Test install in a staging theme and run Lighthouse scores.
• Confirm script loading patterns—deferred loading is preferred to avoid harming page speed.
• Ask the vendor whether scripts are hosted on their CDN and how they handle outages.

Neither listing specifies performance guarantees; merchants should test directly.

Merchant Use Cases and Recommendations

Best For SWishlist: Simple Wishlist

• Small-to-midsize merchants who want a focused wishlist without feature bloat.
• Stores needing reliable localization options (Premium plan supports 20 languages).
• Merchants who value strong app-store reputation and predictable support SLAs.
• Teams that can integrate via API if they want to tie wishlist events into custom marketing flows.

Suggested actions:

• Start on the Free plan to test up to 300 additions/month. Upgrade to Basic ($5/month) when usage grows.
• Use Premium when unlimited wishlist additions and richer stats are required.

Best For K Wish List‑Advanced Wishlist

• Stores that want multiple on-page wishlist placements out of the box (floating, header, popup).
• Merchants focusing on social sharing and gift-list features (holiday campaigns, wedding registries).
• Non-technical stores that want a no-code setup and quick visual configuration.
• Stores that need to surface wishlist CTAs aggressively across the site to drive saves.

Suggested actions:

• Install the Free plan to test different placement options and social sharing before upgrading.
• Confirm any usage limits or support response levels before committing to Growth tiers.

When Not to Choose Either

• Merchants who want an integrated retention stack (loyalty, referrals, reviews, VIP tiers) in addition to a wishlist will find single-purpose apps create tool sprawl and integration complexity.
• High-volume enterprise brands that require native integration with enterprise email, subscription platforms, or headless architectures should evaluate platforms designed for broader retention use cases.

Migration and Implementation Considerations

When adding or replacing wishlist apps, merchants should consider:

• Data migration: Can existing wishlists be exported from the current app and imported into the new one? SWishlist’s API likely supports export; confirm with Kaktus.
• Theme changes: Will theme customizations break when switching apps? Test in staging.
• Tracking and events: Ensure wishlist events are tracked in analytics and marketing tools; confirm if webhooks or API events exist.
• Performance: Test site speed after installation and before going live.

Practical checklist (use as a pre-launch workflow during migration):

• Confirm export of existing wishlist records.
• Test new app in staging theme and run site-speed audits.
• Validate wishlist behavior for logged-in and guest users.
• Confirm marketing events are firing (e.g., in GA4 or Klaviyo).
• Confirm support contact and SLA if a critical issue appears.

The Alternative: Solving App Fatigue with an All-in-One Platform

Single-purpose tools solve immediate problems rapidly—but adding multiple single-point apps increases maintenance, creates fragmented data, and can slow marketing velocity. This accumulation of tools is often described as "app fatigue": the hidden cost of stitching together multiple vendors for related retention functions.

App fatigue issues:

• Fragmented data: Wishlists, loyalty points, referral events, and reviews live in different dashboards, making it hard to build unified customer segments.
• Increased integration work: Each app may require distinct APIs, webhooks, or middleware.
• UX inconsistencies: Multiple UIs and cross-app behaviors create inconsistent customer experiences.
• Rising total cost of ownership: Multiple subscriptions, developer hours, and support tickets add up.

Growave’s "More Growth, Less Stack" proposition responds to these challenges by combining loyalty, referrals, reviews, wishlist, and VIP tiers into a single retention platform. This reduces the need to maintain separate tools for adjacent retention functions and centralizes customer data for easier segmentation and automation.

Key benefits of a consolidated approach:

• Single customer profile: Wishlist saves, reward balances, referral status, and review activity are visible together for better personalization.
• Fewer integrations to maintain: One vendor handles most retention flows and integrates with common marketing platforms.
• Cohesive UX: Branded programs and consistent messaging across loyalty and wishlist touchpoints.
• Faster campaign execution: Combine wishlist-triggered rewards, referral bonuses for shared wishlists, and email automations from one dashboard.

For merchants evaluating consolidation, Growave offers multiple entry points and features to consider. Merchants can compare plans and pick an option that matches order volume and required features; pricing and plan details are available to assess expected costs and scale. Explore how to consolidate retention features and pricing transparency on Growave’s plans to determine fit for a specific store.

consolidate retention features

Book a personalized demo to see how an integrated retention stack improves retention. Book a personalized demo

Growave Feature Highlights (How an all-in-one compares)

Loyalty & Rewards

A robust loyalty program rewards repeat purchases and behaviors beyond transactions. Growave enables merchants to configure points for purchases, wishlist saves, reviews, referrals, and custom actions—so wishlist activity contributes to lifetime value directly. Merchants can build loyalty and rewards that drive repeat purchases without wiring points systems across multiple vendors.

Growave offers tiered plans with increasing customizability and support, allowing stores to move from a basic loyalty program to complex VIP tiers and custom reward actions as they scale.

Reviews & UGC

Gathering customer reviews and user-generated content is a key lever for social proof. With Growave, merchants can collect and showcase authentic reviews and pair that content with loyalty incentives—encouraging reviewers with points or rewards.

This integrated approach reduces manual workflows; the same platform that collects reviews can reward reviewers and display content in a cohesive way.

Wishlist, Referrals, and VIP Tiers

Growave’s wishlist tool ties directly into referrals and VIP mechanics. For example, wishlist sharing can be incentivized by referral rewards, or heavy wishlist engagement can feed VIP tier eligibility. These are cross-product flows that are costly to emulate when using separate apps for each function.

Integrations and Plus-Level Support

Growave supports enterprise-level needs—integrations with Klaviyo, Omnisend, Recharge, and headless/Plus architectures. For merchants on scalable platforms or those considering Shopify Plus, Growave provides specialized capabilities tailored for high-growth brands and solutions for high-growth Plus brands.

Customer Stories and Real-World Examples

Merchants evaluating platforms should review how similar brands use integrated retention stacks. Growave provides customer stories and inspiration, illustrating practical implementations and performance outcomes from consolidating tools. Review customer stories from brands scaling retention to see use cases and performance signals.

Pricing and Trial

Growave’s pricing is structured to grow with merchant needs: an entry plan for early growth, a mid-tier with more customization, and an enterprise Plus plan for large-scale operations. Details on plans, feature breakdowns, and inclusive services are accessible so merchants can calculate ROI versus multiple single-purpose apps.

Compare plans and feature sets, and evaluate total subscription costs versus the cumulative cost of individual apps. See how an integrated plan could lower complexity and improve lifetime value while offering a predictable budget. Merchants can compare options and sign up for trial or arrange a demo to evaluate fit.

consolidate retention features
install Growave from the Shopify App Store

Practical Decision Framework: Choosing the Right Approach

To make an objective selection, merchants should map business priorities, technical resources, and growth targets to app capabilities. The following guidance helps translate needs into a practical decision:

• If the primary requirement is a lightweight wishlist with minimal setup and a low monthly cost, and the store has modest wishlist volumes, choose SWishlist: Simple Wishlist. Its 4.9 rating (106 reviews) signals reliability and merchant satisfaction.
• If visual placement flexibility and social sharing are central—especially for gift-oriented or event-driven selling—and the store lacks developer resources, choose K Wish List‑Advanced Wishlist for its floating button, popup, and embedded page options.
• If the store wants to combine wishlist behavior with loyalty incentives, referrals, reviews, VIP tiers, and unified analytics—avoid stitching multiple apps together and evaluate Growave’s integrated approach to reduce overhead and unlock cross-product workflows.

Implementation Playbooks

Below are concise, action-oriented playbooks for three common merchant scenarios. These are advisory and avoid narrative hypotheticals.

Playbook: Fast, Low-Cost Wishlist Launch

• Install K Wish List (free) or SWishlist (free).
• Configure placement (floating button or header icon).
• Test wishlist save behavior on mobile and desktop.
• Promote wishlist during seasonal campaigns to measure save-to-purchase conversion.

Playbook: Localized Wishlist for Multi-Language Stores

• Choose SWishlist Premium for expanded language support (up to 20 languages).
• Use free setup on initial themes to ensure proper locale rendering.
• Export wishlist usage stats and monitor best-saved items per region.

Playbook: Integrated Retention Strategy (Wishlist + Loyalty + Reviews)

• Evaluate Growave’s plans and integrations.
• Design rewards for wishlist saves and reviews to increase LTV.
• Coordinate a launch with email flows and referral incentives to convert wishlist saves into purchases.
• Monitor cohort retention and upgrade plan as order volume and program complexity grow.

consolidate retention features
collect and showcase authentic reviews

Support Checklist Before Committing

Before installing any wishlist app, confirm the following with the vendor:

• Data export and import capabilities for wishlists and user associations.
• Explicit support SLAs and escalation paths.
• Known page speed impacts and available optimization options.
• How the app handles logged-in vs guest user flows.
• Whether wishlist events can be forwarded to marketing platforms natively or via API/webhooks.

Conclusion

For merchants choosing between SWishlist: Simple Wishlist and K Wish List‑Advanced Wishlist, the decision comes down to priorities. SWishlist excels as a focused, highly rated wishlist tool with clear upgrade paths, good localization, and predictable support SLAs—making it an excellent choice for stores that need a reliable, low-cost wishlist. K Wish List‑Advanced Wishlist offers more on-page placement options and social sharing features that suit gift-driven campaigns and stores that prefer rapid, no-code visual control.

For merchants who want to reduce tool sprawl and connect wishlist behavior to broader retention programs—loyalty, referrals, reviews, and VIP tiers—an integrated platform delivers better long-term value. Growave’s "More Growth, Less Stack" approach consolidates multiple retention features into a single system, simplifying data, reducing integration overhead, and enabling cross-functional campaigns that boost customer lifetime value. Learn more about plan options and how consolidation compares to a multi-app approach by reviewing Growave’s pricing and plans.

Start a 14-day free trial to explore Growave's integrated retention stack. Start a 14-day free trial

install Growave from the Shopify App Store

FAQ

Q: Which app is easier to set up for non-technical merchants?
A: K Wish List‑Advanced Wishlist emphasizes no-code setup and multiple display options (floating button, header icon, popup, embedded), making it particularly friendly for non-technical merchants. SWishlist also offers free setup support (up to two themes) and easy configuration, but merchants who prioritize visual placement may find K Wish List slightly simpler to configure without developer support.

Q: Which app offers better long-term value if a store plans to expand loyalty and referral programs?
A: Both SWishlist and K Wish List are solid wishlist solutions, but they remain single-purpose tools. Stores planning to expand into loyalty, referrals, and reviews should evaluate an integrated platform to avoid multiple subscriptions and integration complexity. An integrated platform can turn wishlist behavior into loyalty points and referral incentives without stitching together separate apps.

Q: How do the apps compare on ratings and merchant reputation?
A: SWishlist: Simple Wishlist has 106 reviews with a 4.9 rating, indicating strong merchant satisfaction. K Wish List‑Advanced Wishlist has 81 reviews with a 4.7 rating—also positive but with slightly fewer reviews and marginally lower average score. Both are credible options, but SWishlist’s higher review count and rating offer stronger social proof.

Q: How does an all-in-one platform compare to specialized wishlist apps?
A: Specialized wishlist apps deliver quick, focused functionality that often fits the immediate need. An all-in-one platform, however, consolidates wishlist, loyalty, referrals, reviews, and VIP tiers into one system. This approach reduces data fragmentation, simplifies marketing automation, and enables cross-product campaigns (for example, rewarding wishlist saves with points). For stores that expect to scale retention efforts, the all-in-one route often provides better value and fewer long-term headaches. Review plan details and feature parity to confirm fit before migrating.