Stensiled Wishlist vs. SE Wishlist Engine: An In-Depth Comparison

Introduction

Shopify merchants face a crowded app ecosystem where choosing the right wishlist tool affects conversion, retention, and the number of apps in the store. A wishlist seems small, but it sits at the crossroads of product discovery, email marketing, and repeat purchase flows. Selecting a wishlist app that matches store needs prevents feature gaps, unexpected costs, and extra maintenance work.

Short answer: Stensiled Wishlist is an appropriate choice for merchants who want a lightweight, code-free wishlist with basic analytics and save-for-later behavior at very low cost. SE Wishlist Engine is better for merchants who need richer conversion features—automated wishlist emails, stock/price alerts, integrations with Klaviyo and PageFly, and stronger social proof (249 reviews, 4.9 rating). For merchants aiming to reduce tool sprawl and combine wishlists with loyalty, reviews, and referrals, an integrated platform such as Growave can offer better long-term value.

Purpose of this post: to provide an in-depth, feature-by-feature, and outcome-focused comparison of Stensiled Wishlist and SE Wishlist Engine so merchants can choose the right tool for specific business goals. After the direct comparison, the post explains the trade-offs of single-purpose apps and introduces an all-in-one alternative that reduces technical overhead while improving retention outcomes.

Stensiled Wishlist vs. SE Wishlist Engine: At a Glance

Deep Dive Comparison

This section compares the two apps across specific merchant needs: features, pricing and value, integrations, analytics and data access, customization and UX, support and trust signals, and operational considerations for scaling merchants.

Features

Core wishlist functionality

Stensiled Wishlist

• Focuses on core wishlist functionality: save-for-later, wishlist button icon selection, wishlist analytics, and activity tracking with time-range filters.
• Promotes code-free setup, which reduces the need for a developer to install or maintain the widget.
• Feature set is minimal and intentionally focused on product saving and basic tracking.

SE Wishlist Engine

• Offers a wide suite of wishlist tools beyond simply saving items: guest wishlists (no login required), shareable wishlists, variant detection on product pages, wishlist popups and pages, and social sharing.
• Advanced tiers add price-drop alerts, restock notifications, product recommendations, and unlimited email customization.
• Includes import/export of wishlist data — useful for CRM segmentation and offline analysis.

Practical implication: For stores that only want visitors to save products for a later session, Stensiled covers that core need with minimal fuss. For stores seeking a wishlist to actively drive conversions through automated alerts and reminders, SE Wishlist Engine provides more conversion-oriented features.

Marketing automation and recovery

Stensiled Wishlist

• Does not advertise built-in automated email alerts or price/restock notifications in the provided description.
• Emphasis is on analytics and activity tracking, which could be used to manually trigger campaigns in an external ESP, but that requires extra work.

SE Wishlist Engine

• Includes auto-email sending and configurable alert types (price drop, restock, low-stock).
• Integrates with Klaviyo (and can pass events to Facebook Pixel), enabling stronger personalization and automated follow-up sequences.

Practical implication: Stores that rely on automated lifecycle emails to convert wishlist interest into purchases will find SE’s built-in automation and integrations a clear advantage.

Analytics, reporting, and data access

Stensiled Wishlist

• Markets "detailed wishlist analytics" and activity tracking with time-range filtering.
• Offers insights into which products are saved and customer activity, but no claim of advanced or exportable analytics in the provided description.

SE Wishlist Engine

• Provides basic and advanced insights depending on plan, plus import/export for wishlist records — enabling direct data use in CRMs or spreadsheets.
• Tracks who saved which products and offers reports on the most saved products.

Practical implication: SE gives more actionable, exportable analytics on higher tiers. Stensiled probably covers basic reporting needs, but merchants that require data flows into CRMs or ESPs should verify export possibilities.

Customer experience features

Stensiled Wishlist

• Custom icons for buttons, save-for-later functionality, and code-free setup create a simple UX for customers and merchants.
• Unknown whether guest wishlist or social sharing is supported (not listed).

SE Wishlist Engine

• Guest wishlist, shareable lists, wishlist popups and pages, language options and multi-currency (on Premium), and variant-change detection make for a richer customer experience.
• Social sharing and guest access can reduce friction and increase viral reach.

Practical implication: If the priority is a frictionless customer experience (no login required) and viral/shareable wishlists, SE has the more complete feature set.

Pricing & Value

Pricing is a major decision factor—consider both sticker price and the business outcomes enabled by the features.

Stensiled Wishlist pricing

• Basic Plan: Free — code-free setup, wishlist analytics, custom icons, save for later, activity tracking with time ranges.
• Advance Plan: $9.99 / month — same feature list suggests the paid tier may unlock usage limits or support; specifics on limits aren’t provided.

Value assessment:

• Stensiled offers an entry point with no cost and a single paid tier at $9.99. For merchants who only need basic wishlist functionality without automation or integrations, this is a low monthly outlay and therefore good value for money when minimalism is acceptable.

SE Wishlist Engine pricing

• Free Plan: Free — up to 100 wishlist items, basic customization, wishlist page & popup, sharing, languages, basic insights.
• Basic Plan: $7.99 / month — unlimited wishlist items, hide branding, basic insights, sharing.
• Advanced Plan: $14.99 / month — wishlist reminders, low stock alerts, price-drop and restock alerts, product recommendations, import/export, unlimited emails, Facebook pixel & Klaviyo integrations, advanced insights.
• Premium Plan: $21.99 / month — includes advanced insights, multi-language/multi-currency, multi-language email templates, product recommendation.

Value assessment:

• SE presents more pricing tiers that align with incremental marketing and conversion features. For stores that plan to use wishlist-triggered emails, price alerts, or make wishlist data actionable in Klaviyo, SE’s paid tiers can create measurable incremental revenue and thus represent better value for money than a minimal offering.

Comparative pricing note:

• A merchant should compare the cost of buying SE’s advanced features (e.g., $14.99–$21.99/mo) with the cost to implement equivalent behaviors using Stensiled plus separate integrations and manual flows. Often, the bundled automation in SE will be cheaper and faster to implement than combining a basic wishlist with third-party automation.

Integrations & Ecosystem Fit

Integrations make wishlist data usable in other channels and allow wishlist events to trigger automated campaigns.

SE Wishlist Engine

• Explicitly lists integrations: Klaviyo (email personalization and automations), PageFly (page builder compatibility), and Facebook Pixel for ad retargeting. This helps turn wishlist interactions into retargeting audiences and email flows.
• Import/export features allow data to be moved into CRMs or analytics tools.

Stensiled Wishlist

• No explicit "Works With" integrations provided in the given data. The code-free setup suggests a lightweight widget, but merchants should confirm whether it exposes events via webhooks, integrates with ESPs, or supports export.

Practical implication: Stores that rely on advanced ESPs and ad platforms for lifecycle campaigns should prefer an app that connects directly to those platforms. SE’s integrations reduce engineering overhead and accelerate launch.

Customization, Theme Compatibility, and Installation

Setup complexity

Stensiled Wishlist

• Markets code-free setup, which implies quick installation and minimal developer involvement for standard themes.

SE Wishlist Engine

• Also appears designed for non-technical setup but offers features (variant change detection, popups) that sometimes require slight theme adjustments. SE’s documentation should clarify whether manual theme edits are needed for specific themes or headless setups.

Practical implication: For merchants with minimal design resources who want a plug-and-play solution, both apps may work, but Stensiled emphasizes the code-free promise more directly. For stores using PageFly or heavy customizations, SE’s PageFly compatibility is an advantage.

Design flexibility

Stensiled Wishlist

• Custom icons selection and basic button customizations are mentioned. Deeper styling capabilities are not described.

SE Wishlist Engine

• Includes button and icon customization, popup and wishlist page templates, and multi-language UI on premium plans. For merchants wanting to maintain a branded UX across wishlist touchpoints, SE offers more serve-and-style options.

Practical implication: High-visual brands that demand tight design control will likely prefer apps with more UI and pop-up customization—SE better fits that need.

Analytics, Data Portability & Compliance

Data ownership and export matter when wishlist data is going to be fed into segmentation or recovery programs.

SE Wishlist Engine

• Offers import/export, advanced insights on higher tiers, and integration with Klaviyo. These capabilities enable direct audience building and email triggers.
• Facebook Pixel integration allows building custom audiences for retargeting wishlist users.

Stensiled Wishlist

• Lists "detailed wishlist analytics" and time-range tracking, but does not explicitly promise export or integrations in the provided data. Merchants should confirm whether event-level data can be exported or streamed.

Privacy and compliance:

• Any merchant using wishlist data to send emails or target ads must confirm data storage practices, consent handling for guest wishlists, and alignment with GDPR/CCPA if applicable. SE’s integration hints at more event passing, but merchants should request documentation from either vendor to confirm compliance controls.

Practical implication: Merchants that must move wishlist data between systems or require strict record retention policies should prioritize apps that explicitly support export and integration.

Support, Reviews, and Vendor Maturity

User reviews are a proxy for reliability, support quality, and real-world fit.

SE Wishlist Engine

• 249 reviews with an average rating of 4.9 is strong social proof. This suggests an established user base, frequent updates, and responsive support for common merchant issues.

Stensiled Wishlist

• 0 reviews and 0 rating implies a very new app or one not widely installed. Lack of reviews increases uncertainty about long-term stability, support responsiveness, and compatibility across themes and third-party apps.

Practical implication: Established app adoption and high review scores reduce perceived risk. Stores that prefer a safer, battle-tested choice may favor SE based on public feedback.

Operational Considerations & Scaling

Maintenance and conflicts

• Single-purpose apps with limited integrations can be light to maintain initially but often lead to more apps as merchants seek added functionality (alerts, emails, loyalty).
• Feature expansion in SE reduces the need for additional apps (email alerts, export), whereas Stensiled stores may add separate email or automation tools.

Migration and growth

• As merchants grow and require multi-channel retention programs, wishlist functionality often needs to sit alongside loyalty programs, referrals, and reviews. Migrating wishlist data and unifying customer records across separate vendor systems can be time-consuming.
• SE’s export/import helps migration, but merchants should confirm API access or data export formats before committing.

Practical implication: Merchants likely to scale should think earlier about how wishlist data will feed other retention programs—this affects whether to buy an advanced wishlist or to move to an integrated platform later.

Side-by-Side Feature Checklist

• Wishlist saving and Save for Later:
  • Stensiled: Yes
  • SE: Yes
• Guest wishlist (no login):
  • Stensiled: Not specified
  • SE: Yes
• Shareable wishlist / social sharing:
  • Stensiled: Not specified
  • SE: Yes
• Automated emails (price drop, restock, reminders):
  • Stensiled: Not specified
  • SE: Yes (Advanced/ Premium)
• Data export / import:
  • Stensiled: Not specified
  • SE: Yes
• Integrations with Klaviyo / Page builders:
  • Stensiled: Not specified
  • SE: Klaviyo, PageFly
• Multi-language / multi-currency:
  • Stensiled: Not specified
  • SE: Premium plan supports multi-language & multi-currency
• Free plan available:
  • Stensiled: Yes
  • SE: Yes (limits)

Strengths and Weaknesses — Neutral Summary

Stensiled Wishlist

• Strengths:
  • Simple, code-free setup that suits merchants wanting minimal overhead.
  • Free plan available for basic use or testing.
  • Core wishlist analytics and time-range tracking for basic insights.
• Weaknesses:
  • No public reviews in the dataset, creating uncertainty about support and compatibility.
  • Limited shown integrations and automation—may require additional apps to capture the same conversion lift as automated alert systems.
  • Unclear export capabilities.

SE Wishlist Engine

• Strengths:
  • Robust feature set that includes automation (emails, alerts), integrations (Klaviyo, Facebook Pixel), and data export.
  • Strong social proof: 249 reviews with an average rating of 4.9.
  • Tiered pricing that scales with feature needs and offers multi-language/multi-currency on premium plans.
• Weaknesses:
  • Paid tiers required to access automation features—free tier has useful limits (100 items).
  • Extra features can create additional configuration needs; merchants should test flows to avoid duplicate emails or conflicts with existing ESP triggers.

Which App Is Best For Which Merchant?

• Merchants on a tight budget who need only a simple save-for-later or basic wishlist, want plug-and-play installation, and have no need for automated alerts: Stensiled is a solid, low-friction choice.
• Merchants who want to convert wishlist interest into sales via automated email reminders, price/restock alerts, and direct integration with Klaviyo or Facebook advertising: SE Wishlist Engine is the better fit.
• Merchants who plan to scale retention strategies beyond wishlists—adding loyalty, referrals, and reviews—and want to avoid tool sprawl should evaluate integrated platforms that package these capabilities together.

The Alternative: Solving App Fatigue with an All-in-One Platform

Single-purpose apps solve one problem well, but running many single-point solutions creates "app fatigue"—the cumulative cost, overlapping features, theme conflicts, and multiple vendor relationships that distract from growth goals. Wishlist apps are a good example: a store may start with a lightweight wishlist but later add email automation, loyalty rewards, review collection, and referral incentives—each often requires another app and more maintenance.

Consolidating functionality into a unified retention platform reduces overhead, centralizes customer data, and ensures consistent user experiences across touchpoints. The "More Growth, Less Stack" approach prioritizes outcomes—retention, LTV, and repeat purchase—over stitching together multiple apps.

Growave’s proposition is built around the idea that wishlists are most effective when combined with loyalty, referrals, and reviews. Merchants can consolidate retention features on a single platform rather than managing separate vendors for each capability. For merchants evaluating consolidation, it helps to compare both the total cost of ownership and the operational cost (maintenance, theme conflicts, data reconciliation) of multiple apps versus a single integrated suite.

• For merchants who want to consolidate retention features and compare plans, see the Growave pricing options: consolidate retention features.
• To explore how Growave integrates with the Shopify ecosystem, including installation options, merchants can install from the Shopify App Store.

What an integrated retention stack delivers

• Unified customer records so wishlist events feed into loyalty segments without manual exports.
• Centralized automation rules that prevent duplicate messages from multiple systems.
• Native cross-feature promotions: for example, converting wishlist saves into loyalty reward incentives or targeted review requests after a wishlist conversion.
• Streamlined support from a single vendor for retention features rather than contacting multiple apps for an issue that spans several flows.

Growave combines wishlist functionality with loyalty, reviews & UGC collection, referrals, and VIP tiers. That combination reduces the need to maintain separate systems for each retention tactic and increases the odds that wishlist engagement will translate into higher lifetime value.

• Merchants looking to build loyalty and rewards that drive repeat purchases can review how those capabilities work in Growave: loyalty and rewards that drive repeat purchases.
• Those focused on social proof and conversion rate impact can learn how to collect and showcase authentic reviews: collect and showcase authentic reviews.

Book a personalized demo to see how an integrated retention stack improves retention.
Book a personalized demo

How Growave compares to standalone wishlists

• Data centralization: Growave connects wishlist events directly to loyalty segments and referral campaigns, so customer actions have immediate programmatic value.
• Reduced integration overhead: Instead of configuring a wishlist app to pass data into Klaviyo or a referral platform, Growave exposes these features natively or via fewer, better-documented integrations.
• Simplified UX consistency: Design language and email templates are managed centrally—reducing friction and preserving brand consistency across loyalty prompts, wishlist reminders, and review requests.

For stores that prefer to install a single provider and test quickly, it’s possible to install from the Shopify App Store and evaluate features in context.

Who benefits most from consolidating

• Fast-growing brands that want to scale retention without multiplying vendor relationships.
• Stores using loyalty or VIP tiers where wishlist events should impact tier progression or reward eligibility.
• Merchants who prioritize customer lifetime value and want a single source of truth for retention metrics rather than reconciling data across multiple apps.

Merchants can compare plans and features directly on Growave’s pricing page to assess feature overlap and the cost-to-benefit of consolidation: compare plans.

Implementation & Migration Considerations

If moving from a single-purpose wishlist to a consolidated platform or replacing one wishlist with another, the following operational checklist helps reduce migration friction:

• Export wishlist records (user IDs, product IDs, timestamps). SE Wishlist Engine supports import/export on paid plans; confirm Stensiled’s export capabilities or request them from the vendor.
• Map identifiers: ensure product SKUs or Shopify variant IDs align between systems to avoid orphaned wishlist items.
• Decide on duplication behavior: will new wishlist adds create duplicates, update existing lists, or merge? Set rules before launch.
• Recreate critical automations: wishlist reminders, price-drop emails, and loyalty triggers must be reproduced or ported. Use vendor migration guides where available.
• Staged rollout: enable the new wishlist feature for a small percentage of traffic first to surface conflicts with theme code or other apps.
• Monitor KPIs: track wishlist saves, wishlist-to-order conversion rate, email open/click-to-conversion, and any changes in support volume after the switch.

If a merchant plans to use wishlist events for lifecycle marketing, evaluate whether the destination platform supports real-time event passing (webhooks) or only batch exports.

Final Feature Comparison Snapshot

• Best for simple, low-cost wishlist: Stensiled Wishlist (Basic free plan).
• Best for conversion-focused wishlist with advanced automation and integrations: SE Wishlist Engine (Advanced/Premium plans).
• Best for long-term retention and reduced tool sprawl: Growave’s integrated platform—combining wishlist, loyalty, referrals, and reviews.

For a one-stop evaluation and to see how consolidation affects total cost of ownership and retention outcomes, merchants can review Growave pricing: consolidate retention features and consider installing from the App Store: install from the Shopify App Store.

Conclusion

For merchants choosing between Stensiled Wishlist and SE Wishlist Engine, the decision comes down to scope and outcomes. Stensiled is a good fit for stores that want a lightweight, code-free wishlist with basic analytics at the lowest monthly cost. SE Wishlist Engine is better for stores that plan to drive conversions through automated alerts, exportable data, and integrations with Klaviyo and ad platforms—its 249 reviews and 4.9 rating reflect strong user satisfaction.

When the goal expands beyond a single retention touchpoint, consolidating wishlist functionality with loyalty, reviews, and referrals can reduce technical overhead and improve long-term retention metrics. Growave offers a multi-tool retention suite designed to replace multiple single-purpose apps and centralize customer data for repeat purchase growth. Merchants can evaluate plans and test consolidation options by visiting the Growave pricing page: consolidate retention features and reviewing the Shopify installation options: install from the Shopify App Store.

Start a 14-day free trial to explore how combining wishlist, loyalty, reviews, and referrals in a single platform affects retention and lifetime value.
Start a 14-day free trial

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: How do Stensiled Wishlist and SE Wishlist Engine differ in driving conversions?
A: SE Wishlist Engine includes built-in automated emails (price-drop, restock, reminders) and integrations (Klaviyo, Facebook Pixel) that directly convert wishlist interest into purchase opportunities. Stensiled focuses on core wishlist saving and analytics; conversion-driving automation would require external systems.

Q: Which app offers better integrations with ESPs and page builders?
A: SE Wishlist Engine explicitly lists Klaviyo and PageFly among its integrations. Stensiled’s provided data does not list integrations; merchants should request integration details before choosing.

Q: Is SE Wishlist Engine worth the upgrade for small stores on a budget?
A: If the store expects wishlist-triggered emails to materially influence revenue (e.g., price-sensitive or low-stock product categories), the Advanced tier’s automation could pay for itself. For stores that only need product saving and minimal maintenance, the free or low-cost options may be sufficient.

Q: How does an all-in-one platform compare to specialized wishlist apps?
A: An integrated platform centralizes customer data and retention programs, reducing app conflicts and manual exports. It may cost more monthly than a single lightweight wishlist but often delivers better ROI by enabling cross-feature tactics (e.g., loyalty rewards for wishlist conversions), reducing management time, and streamlining support. For some merchants, consolidating multiple needs into one trusted vendor is better value for money over time.