Smart Wishlist vs. XB Wishlist: An In-Depth Comparison

Introduction

Choosing the right wishlist app is one of those deceptively important decisions for Shopify merchants. Wishlists can increase conversions, revive browser abandoners, and give clear signals about demand — but a poorly chosen app can create theme conflicts, fragment data, or add recurring costs without meaningful return.

Short answer: Smart Wishlist is a good, low-cost option for merchants who want a lightweight, no-code wishlist that works for guest and logged-in users. XB Wishlist focuses on a polished, account-centric experience with built-in activity analytics and design controls, and it earns high satisfaction from a small set of reviewers. For merchants who want to consolidate retention features and reduce tool sprawl, a unified platform like Growave offers stronger long-term value through integrated loyalty, referrals, reviews, and wishlist capabilities.

This article provides a practical, feature-by-feature comparison of Smart Wishlist (by Webmarked) and XB Wishlist (by XB), evaluates pricing and integrations, and outlines which merchants should choose each app. After a fair comparison, the article explains how an all-in-one retention platform can address limitations that single-purpose wishlist apps introduce.

Smart Wishlist vs. XB Wishlist: At a Glance

Deep Comparison

Product Positioning and Philosophy

Smart Wishlist: Minimal, fast, guest-friendly

Smart Wishlist positions itself as the "next-generation wishlist" that prioritizes speed, ease of setup, and guest access. Its core promise is one-click saving without requiring logins, and the developer highlights a lightweight payload so themes remain stable after uninstall. That positions Smart Wishlist toward merchants who want the least friction for customers and the least engineering overhead for teams.

XB Wishlist: Account-first with analytics

XB Wishlist frames its value around improving the customer journey and increasing repeat visits. The app emphasizes integration with customer accounts, visual customization, and activity tracking. This suggests a slightly more feature-rich proposition for merchants who want to analyze wishlist behavior and keep data tied to authenticated customers.

Features Compared

Both apps implement the essential wishlist functions, but there are meaningful differences in scope and intent.

Core Wishlist Capabilities

Smart Wishlist and XB Wishlist share key user-facing capabilities:

• Wishlist buttons on product pages and other catalog locations.
• Shareable wishlists.
• Support for saving items and later retrieval.

Smart Wishlist has a stronger emphasis on guest usage, enabling wishlist creation without an account. XB Wishlist emphasizes access from customer accounts and offers customization for design elements.

Advanced Customization & Developer Tools

Smart Wishlist explicitly lists JavaScript and REST APIs, which helps merchants with development resources extend behavior (sync to external systems, custom UI). Its lightweight approach reduces theme override risk.

XB Wishlist does not advertise public REST/JS APIs in the provided data, but it supports design tailoring of the wishlist button and tracks activity with built-in analytics. For merchants without developer bandwidth who still want a polished UI and analytics, XB covers that need.

Analytics & Behavioral Signals

XB Wishlist states it provides "built-in analytics" for tracking wishlist activity — a valuable feature for merchandising and re-marketing. Smart Wishlist does not emphasize native analytics in its feature list, so merchants relying on wishlist data to inform inventory, re-engagement flows, or ad targeting may need to add separate tracking.

Sharing & Social

Both apps support shareable lists, which is important for gift registries or social shopping. Smart Wishlist mentions compatibility with ShareThis, suggesting options for social sharing integrations. XB Wishlist’s share features are described as part of the core experience without name-checking third-party sharing services.

Multi-wishlist & Scale

Smart Wishlist touts "unlimited wishlists across all stores" which is useful for multi-product bookmarkers and stores running campaigns or registries. XB Wishlist’s data doesn’t call out wishlist limits, so merchants should confirm limits for high-volume use cases (gift registries, large families).

Setup, UI, and Merchant Experience

Installation & Setup

Smart Wishlist markets "super-easy to setup with no coding required" and promises minimal theme alteration and safe uninstall behavior. That can reduce friction during onboarding and provide confidence for merchants experimenting with wishlist features.

XB Wishlist also emphasizes simple setup and seamless integration, but its account-focused design may require linking to the customer's account pages or subtle theme placement adjustments. Merchants should expect to confirm theme compatibility and placement during onboarding.

Customer-Facing UX

Smart Wishlist’s guest-first design reduces one common friction point: forced account creation. Allowing anonymous wishlist creation typically increases usage among first-time and occasional visitors. That creates a smoother path from browsing to eventual conversion.

XB Wishlist’s design control and customer-account integration produce a more cohesive experience for returning customers. Saved items tied to accounts are persistent across devices and can be leveraged in personalized email flows and loyalty experiences.

Theme and Performance Impact

Smart Wishlist emphasizes a lightweight payload and claims it "doesn't break your theme upon uninstall." That is a meaningful operational claim: theme conflicts are a common source of post-install issues. XB Wishlist’s UX focus and built-in analytics imply it may load more assets, but that is not explicitly confirmed; merchants should ask about script sizes and secondarily measure site speed after trial installs.

Pricing & Value

Smart Wishlist Pricing

Smart Wishlist lists a Standard plan at $4.99 / month. There are no other plans provided in the data. For merchants seeking a low-cost, single-purpose wishlist that supports guest saving and shareable lists, this is straightforward value for money.

Benefits of Smart Wishlist pricing:

• Low monthly commitment fits lean budgets.
• Predictable cost for a single function.

Limitations:

• A single-purpose app at $4.99/month can seem economical initially, but adding other retention tools increases total app costs and creates data silos.

XB Wishlist Pricing

XB Wishlist’s pricing is not included in the provided data. The app may be free, paid, or charge based on features; merchants should contact the developer or install the app to see pricing. XB’s rating of 5.0 across 19 reviews suggests the users who installed it were satisfied with features and likely found it good value for money, but limited public pricing transparency requires direct validation.

Value Considerations

A few practical pricing questions merchants should evaluate:

• Does the app charge per wishlist or per active user?
• Are analytics or API features behind paywalls?
• Are there setup or customization fees?

From a strategic perspective, single-purpose apps are often less expensive individually than all-in-one solutions, but combining multiple single-purpose tools multiplies ongoing costs, increases integration work, and can fracture customer data.

Integrations & Extensibility

Integration compatibility is a major operational consideration.

Smart Wishlist Integrations

Smart Wishlist works with SendGrid and ShareThis and exposes JavaScript and REST APIs for custom integrations. That provides ways to wire wishlist events into email platforms, tag users in marketing tools, or export lists for manual outreach.

XB Wishlist Integrations

XB Wishlist lists Shopify Flow among its integrations, enabling automated workflow actions through Shopify's automation platform. Built-in analytics can also feed merchant insights without exporting data to third-party systems.

Which Integrations Matter Most

Merchants should map wishlist events to:

• Email automation platforms (e.g., Klaviyo, Omnisend) for abandoned wishlist flows.
• CRM or support tools for wishlist inquiries.
• Ads/retargeting platforms to build audiences from high-intent signals.

If a wishlist app lacks a direct integration to the merchant’s stack, the JavaScript/REST APIs in Smart Wishlist can bridge the gap, while XB’s Shopify Flow support may enable internal automation without third-party connectors.

Reporting, Measurement & Attribution

XB Wishlist

XB Wishlist’s mention of built-in analytics is a clear advantage for merchants who want out-of-the-box insights. Merchants can measure how many items are added, who returns to move items into carts, and which products are frequently saved — all actionable for merchandising and paid media targeting.

Smart Wishlist

Smart Wishlist lacks explicit analytics claims in the provided assets. That does not mean measurement is impossible; developers can use the REST/JS APIs to send events to analytics platforms. However, the extra setup required shifts effort to the merchant. For stores without dev resources, analytics absence is limiting.

User Reviews & Support

Ratings and Review Counts

• Smart Wishlist: 81 reviews, rating 3.6. A larger review base with a mid-range rating signals mixed experiences. Common themes to inspect in reviews are support responsiveness, installation conflicts, and feature completeness.
• XB Wishlist: 19 reviews, rating 5.0. Fewer reviews but very high satisfaction among those reviewers. That can indicate a strong fit for specific stores or an app still building its install base.

What to Watch in Reviews

• Theme compatibility reports.
• Speed and page load impact after install.
• Support turnaround and problem resolution.
• Feature gaps discovered after real-world usage (e.g., missing email hooks, lack of multi-wishlist support).

Support Channels

Both apps claim simple setup and support availability, but merchants should test support quality during trial periods. Rapid, helpful support matters more than initial feature lists when dealing with theme quirks or app conflicts.

Data Ownership, Portability & Privacy

Wishlist data can be valuable for merchandising and remarketing. Merchants should confirm:

• How long wishlist data is retained.
• How easy it is to export wishlist data (CSV or API).
• Whether uninstalling the app removes customer data as promised.

Smart Wishlist’s claim of a lightweight payload and no theme breakage is relevant for portability and clean uninstall. For merchants subject to strict privacy requirements, confirm where wishlist data is stored and whether the provider complies with relevant standards.

Performance & Reliability

Script size, asynchronous loading, and CDN usage determine runtime impacts. Smart Wishlist’s emphasis on lightweight payload suggests a minimized performance hit. XB Wishlist’s analytics may load additional assets, so merchants should measure Lighthouse or Core Web Vitals metrics pre- and post-install to quantify impact.

Typical Use Cases and Merchant Recommendations

Below are pragmatic matchings of merchant needs to app choice.

• Merchants with limited budgets and minimal technical resources who only need basic wishlist features (guest saving, shareable lists): Smart Wishlist.
• Brands prioritizing wishlist analytics, polished design, and customer-account integration: XB Wishlist.
• Stores that plan to use wishlist events inside loyalty programs, referral funnels, or reviews: Consider an integrated platform rather than piecing together multiple apps (see the Alternative section below).

Migration & Exit Considerations

An often-overlooked operational question: If the wishlist app needs to be replaced, how easy is migration? Smart Wishlist’s API and lightweight data model may simplify exports. Merchants should confirm both apps’ export capabilities before committing.

The Alternative: Solving App Fatigue with an All-in-One Platform

Single-purpose wishlist apps solve a discrete problem. However, many merchants experience "app fatigue": the operational friction that accumulates when multiple single-function tools are stitched together.

What Is App Fatigue?

App fatigue manifests as:

• Rising monthly app fees for overlapping capabilities.
• Scattered customer data across isolated dashboards.
• More theme and script conflicts as additional apps manipulate storefront elements.
• Longer onboarding cycles for staff who must learn multiple UIs.
• Harder attribution and slower iteration because signals live in silos.

When wishlist events feed into loyalty, referral, and review programs, disconnected apps make it difficult to run coherent retention strategies. Instead of a signal-to-action loop (customer saves item → triggers loyalty points or targeted email → customer returns and purchases), merchants get a stop-start process that wastes momentum.

Growave’s Response: "More Growth, Less Stack"

Growave is positioned as a flexible retention platform designed to replace multiple single-function apps by combining Loyalty and Rewards, Referrals, Reviews & UGC, Wishlist, and VIP Tiers in one suite. This approach reduces tool sprawl and centralizes customer signals.

Key operational benefits:

• One dashboard for loyalty engagement, wishlist signals, referrals, and review capture.
• Native integrations with email and support platforms, lowering integration overhead.
• Enterprise features for Shopify Plus merchants, with multi-language and headless options.

To evaluate the economics and practical value, merchants can review Growave’s pricing and plan tiers on the official pricing page. This side-by-side view helps weigh the cost of a unified platform against stacking multiple single-purpose apps.

How Integrated Wishlist + Loyalty + Reviews Improves Outcomes

Consolidating these retention functions yields concrete advantages:

• Wishlist events can trigger loyalty actions (e.g., awarding points for wishlist creation or converting wishlist items into targeted offers).
• When wishlisted products receive automated incentives, conversion rates rise and average order value improves.
• Reviews and UGC collection can be tied to loyalty rewards, increasing review volume and authenticity.
• Unified customer profiles provide a complete behavior history, enabling smarter segmentation and personalization.

Growave explicitly enables merchants to build loyalty and rewards that drive repeat purchases. That direct coupling between wishlist interactions and retention tactics is difficult to replicate when wishlist data lives in a separate micro-app.

Integrations and Ecosystem Fit

An integrated platform reduces mapping work. Growave lists compatibility with tools many merchants already use, ensuring wishlist signals flow naturally into email automations and support systems. Merchants can view Growave’s App Store listing to see installation options and system requirements.

By consolidating workflows, merchants gain:

• Faster time to value because one platform manages points, referrals, reviews, and wishlists.
• Fewer theme conflicts since only one vendor is adding storefront scripts and UI components.
• Centralized reporting that aligns with retention KPIs (repeat purchase rate, LTV uplift, churn reduction).

Merchants interested in a live walkthrough can also Book a personalized demo to see real-world examples of these integrations and flows.

Cost Comparison and ROI Framing

A careful merchant will compare total monthly spend across multiple single-purpose apps versus an integrated platform. Although a single-purpose wishlist like Smart Wishlist is inexpensive ($4.99/month), the economics shift when adding a reviews app, a loyalty app, and a referral app — each with its own recurring fee.

Growave has tiered plans to match different stages of growth. Merchant teams should evaluate the combined cost of single-purpose apps versus a single Growave plan and factor in the time savings and improved retention outcomes. Detailed pricing and plan features are available on Growave’s pricing page.

When an All-in-One Platform Is Not Ideal

There are scenarios where a single-purpose app still makes sense:

• Extremely small merchants who only need a wishlist and nothing else.
• Stores that already have mature, best-of-breed systems for loyalty or reviews and only need wishlist functionality to fill a gap.
• Highly custom or headless storefronts where a bespoke wishlist is part of a larger engineering roadmap (though Growave has headless and API capabilities for advanced use cases).

For most merchants aiming to scale retention and increase customer lifetime value, reducing the number of vendors and consolidating signals will usually deliver faster, more reliable growth.

Two Practical Next Steps

• If the priority is minimal upfront cost and a guest-first wishlist, test Smart Wishlist for a month and measure wishlist-to-cart conversion.
• If the priority is centralized retention and fewer apps, review Growave pricing and consider a demo to assess how wishlist behavior can feed loyalty, referrals, and reviews within a single platform. Book a personalized demo.

Implementation Checklist: What to Test During a Trial

When testing Smart Wishlist, XB Wishlist, or Growave, use this checklist to validate fit before committing:

• Visual Placement & Theme Impact
  • Confirm wishlist button placement on product and collection pages.
  • Run a site speed check (Core Web Vitals) before and after install.
• User Experience
  • Test wishlist saving as both guest and logged-in user.
  • Share a wishlist link and verify inter-device persistence.
• Data & Integrations
  • Verify export options for wishlist data (CSV/API).
  • Test sending wishlist events to email automation or analytics.
• Reporting & Actionability
  • Check what default analytics are available for wishlist events.
  • Confirm whether wishlist events can trigger rewards, emails, or automations.
• Support & Documentation
  • Reach out to support with a simple question and measure response time and helpfulness.
  • Confirm uninstall behavior and data removal policies.
• Pricing & Roadmap
  • For apps without public pricing, clarify billing model and any usage-based fees.
  • Ask about product roadmap and planned wishlist enhancements.

Migrating from a Single App to an Integrated Platform

If current operations use a wishlist app plus separate loyalty or review tools, migration planning reduces downtime and data loss.

Migration steps to consider:

• Export wishlist data via CSV or API and import into the new platform.
• Identify automation rules tied to wishlist events and recreate them within the integrated tool.
• Schedule a controlled A/B test where a portion of traffic uses the new integrated stack and conversion metrics are compared.
• Communicate changes to customers if UGC or reviews are being migrated or if account access changes.

Growave provides migration support and a customer success model at higher plan tiers, which can simplify this transition for merchants with complex setups. See the available plan options on the pricing page to evaluate which level of onboarding and support suits the merchant’s needs.

Comparative Summary: Which App Is Best For Which Merchant?

• Best for merchants who want a simple, low-cost wishlist with guest support and minimal theme impact: Smart Wishlist (Webmarked) — especially when budget is the primary constraint.
• Best for merchants seeking a polished, account-oriented wishlist with built-in analytics and a high reviewer satisfaction score: XB Wishlist (XB) — suitable for stores that rely on customer accounts and need analytics out of the box.
• Best for merchants prioritizing long-term retention, fewer apps, centralized data, and combined loyalty, referrals, and reviews: Growave — the all-in-one alternative that reduces complexity and aligns wishlist activity with retention programs.

Conclusion

For merchants choosing between Smart Wishlist and XB Wishlist, the decision comes down to priorities: Smart Wishlist offers a lean, guest-friendly wishlist at a very low price point, while XB Wishlist provides an account-centric experience with built-in analytics and a strong reviewer rating. Both are valid choices depending on whether simplicity or analytics-driven merchandising is the priority.

Beyond that choice, consider the broader cost and operational impact of maintaining multiple single-purpose apps. An integrated retention platform can consolidate wishlist behavior with loyalty, referrals, and reviews, enabling direct action on high-intent signals and reducing theme and integration friction. Growave’s "More Growth, Less Stack" approach is designed to help merchants convert wishlist interest into repeat purchases through combined loyalty and review capabilities; review the pricing plans to compare total cost and support levels. Explore Growave pricing to compare plans and features.

Book a personalized demo to see how an integrated retention stack accelerates growth. Book a personalized demo

Start a 14-day free trial to see Growave in action. Start a 14-day free trial

FAQ

Which app is easier to install and keep lightweight on the storefront?

Smart Wishlist emphasizes a lightweight payload and no-theme-breaking uninstall behavior, making it the safer bet for merchants prioritizing minimal impact and quick installation. XB Wishlist also claims simple setup but includes analytics that may add assets; test during trial to confirm performance impact.

If analytics and behavior tracking matter, which app is better?

XB Wishlist explicitly advertises built-in analytics, which gives it an advantage for merchants who want immediate insights without additional engineering. Smart Wishlist offers APIs for custom tracking, but that requires development work to match XB’s out-of-the-box reporting.

How do review counts and ratings influence the choice?

Smart Wishlist has a larger sample of feedback (81 reviews) with a 3.6 rating, indicating a mix of experiences and more public exposure. XB Wishlist’s 19 reviews and 5.0 rating show high satisfaction among a smaller user base. Consider both the quantity and content of reviews when assessing reliability and support.

How does an all-in-one platform compare to specialized apps?

An integrated platform consolidates wishlist signals with loyalty, referrals, and reviews, reducing monthly fees, simplifying data flows, and enabling automated retention strategies. Specialized apps can be cheaper initially and focused on solving a single problem well, but they often increase long-term operational complexity. Merchants should weigh immediate needs against growth plans and the cost of managing multiple tools. For merchants wanting to evaluate consolidation, learn how loyalty and wishlist integration can increase repeat purchases and how to collect and showcase authentic reviews.