Loyalty Program Best Practices for Immediate Business Growth

December 26, 2023

Subscribe to Growave blog

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Transform your Shopify experience with Growave!

Try for Free

There's no denying the importance of incorporating loyalty programs into your marketing strategy. Loyalty programs have been around for quite some time. Due to technological advancements and the rise of e-commerce, they have become a crucial element of any successful business strategy. With so many companies using these programs, their impact on customer loyalty and business growth is undeniable. To better understand and satisfy your customers and ensure their return, consider implementing loyalty programs. 

Use these loyalty program best practices to retain your current customers, increase repeat purchases, and build meaningful relationships.

Loyalty Program Best Practices that Help the Business Grow

Loyalty programs strengthen the connection between the brand and its customers, turning a basic business relationship into a vibrant network of brand advocates. Every customer wants to be seen and appreciated. Any business aiming to enhance customer loyalty and retention should be familiar with these effective loyalty strategies to ensure the success of its loyalty program. Although loyalty programs are an effective tool in retaining current customers and winning back lost ones, they aren’t cheap. These programs must be engaging to encourage customers to come back. This isn’t always easy. Even big companies can lose money if they use the wrong strategies. 

So, let’s learn the best practices that work: 

01. Make it Easy to Join and Use

Ensuring that loyalty programs are easy to join is always a smart idea. The easier the process, the better. If a program takes too long to sign up or asks for too much information, fewer customers will subscribe. Always keep the customer in mind. If your loyalty program is user-friendly enough to encourage everyone to sign up, you've ensured its success. In today's busy world, simplicity is key. Avoid complicating your customers' lives. This means that your loyalty program should feature straightforward messaging and clearly explain the rules and conditions of the rewards program. Ensure that rewards are easy to receive. Difficulties in redeeming rewards can also discourage customers. Remember, a well-designed loyalty program is not only easy to use but also effective in creating a loyal following.

For example, joining the rewards program at Chubbies is a straightforward and hassle-free process. Check their landing page to see for yourself.

The Chubbies loyalty program landing page

The Chubbies rewards program's landing page design is a perfect example of how to do it right. Strategically placed “Join Now” and “Login” buttons enhance the landing page's usability. Its content is balanced perfectly, offering customers an engaging experience. It reflects the brand's fun-loving personality, capturing its essence. The design is simple, yet it has everything you need. The overall appearance is crisp, colorful, and captivating.

What makes this landing page so great? 

1. The landing page clearly explains how the program works.

2. Even a first-time visitor can understand the benefits of the program. 

3. The page illustrates the various ways to earn points.

You can easily see how many points you can exchange for each action. 

Many companies overlook the importance of their landing pages. Don’t be one of them. The way you set up and show your customer loyalty program affects how customers see your brand. By doing it right, you can effectively attract and retain your customers' attention. 

02. Continuously Enhance Loyalty Programs

Continuously working on your loyalty programs is crucial for the success of your marketing campaign. If you want to stay relevant in meeting customers' needs and reap ongoing benefits, your loyalty programs should evolve. It’s a win-win for everyone. Your customers receive fresh offers and extra perks from your loyalty program. On the other hand, an engaging rewards program can help you build trust, increase customer loyalty, and boost brand awareness. 

When you regularly update loyalty programs, you keep these programs interesting for customers. This way, you can encourage them to stay engaged and participate actively. What’s more, you give your customers more value by introducing new and relevant features. Conduct surveys regularly to check program satisfaction and track activity-related metrics, including the reward redemption rate. 

Change the way you reward your loyal customers. If you employ a point-based system for every purchase, consider offering rewards for social media shares, likes, and subscriptions. 

For example, Macy’s has modernized their rewards program to better serve its most loyal customers. They’ve introduced a few key changes:

Shipping fees for returns: Shipping back returns for regular customers currently costs $9.99. However, this fee is waived for Star Rewards members, which is a free program open to all.   

Experiential benefits: Members of Star Rewards now have the opportunity to win unique experiences, which enhances the value of the program.

Priority customer service: Customers who spend more money, especially those who use credit cards, get access to better customer service. Based on their spending, these customers are divided into Platinum, Gold, and Silver categories. 

Focus on top customers: Macy's is focusing on its top 10% of consumers, who account for about half of their yearly revenue. They’re offering these high-value customers more significant perks and discounts. 

In general, Macy’s has updated their loyalty program to make it more enticing for their customers. This way they can increase sales by giving members additional benefits and concentrating more on their most valuable customers. 

03. Promote Loyalty Programs on Social Media 

The most recent statistics available indicate that customers use social media for an average of 2 hours and 24 minutes each day. Moreover, there are 4.8 billion social media users worldwide as of 2023

People spend a lot of time posting, and watching videos and photos on social media. Since a vast number of people are active on social media, it’s a strategic move to promote your loyalty programs on these platforms. You can reach people with different interests and backgrounds. Additionally, social media allows for targeted advertising, meaning your rewards program can be showcased to users whose interests align with your offerings. This approach leads to increased engagement rates and better conversion possibilities. Furthermore, social media’s interactive nature provides direct communication with potential customers, fostering a sense of community and loyalty. 

Social media is not just a platform for outreach; it’s a dynamic space for building lasting customer relationships through rewards programs that cater to a wide array of interests and backgrounds.

With such a large user base, promoting your loyalty program on Instagram offers a substantial reach and direct engagement with your current and potential customers. For instance, Yes Darling Tea, a brand known for its wellness tea blends, recently published a post on Instagram. This post helps customers understand how to sign up for their loyalty program on mobile and take advantage of any points they haven't used yet. The visual format makes it straightforward for users to follow along.

That's a good strategy for reminding customers about your loyalty programs. Many companies forget to promote their loyalty programs on social media, and it’s a mistake you can’t afford to make. Leveraging the wide reach and engagement potential of platforms like Instagram can not only increase program visibility but also foster stronger relationships with customers, driving loyalty and brand advocacy. 

04. Personalize your Loyalty Programs 

According to the Twilio Segment, 62% of business leaders think that personalization efforts contribute to better customer retention. Furthermore, 80% of companies claim that personalized experiences increase customer spending.

Personalizing your marketing is crucial because it meets customer expectations. A key advantage of this approach is increased customer engagement. Adding personalization to loyalty programs makes customers feel valued and recognized. It also strengthens their bond with the company. 

When a business tailors its rewards and communications to align with individual preferences and purchase history, it increases the likelihood of repeat business. Customers are more likely to return to a company that cares for them. Personalized loyalty programs give brands the ability to collect customer data. By leveraging data analytics and customer insights, you can anticipate and fulfill your customers’ needs and desires, thereby increasing customer loyalty and conversion rates. This level of personalization cultivates brand advocacy. Additionally, personalization helps you differentiate your brand in a crowded market, by offering unique rewards and benefits that competitors may not provide. You may, for example, give different rewards to customers who shop regularly compared to those who don’t, or you could give discounts on items that a specific customer base usually buys. 

You can also enhance personalization through loyalty program gamification. By utilizing gamification techniques such as surveys, quizzes, challenges, progress bars, and badges, you can make customer interactions with your loyalty programs more enjoyable. This way, your customers will remain loyal to your brand. 

An effective feature commonly used in loyalty programs is 'milestones', which add a gamification aspect to enhance user engagement. To reach a milestone, your customer must accumulate a specific number of points or a certain amount of purchases. 

Costa Coffee is a perfect example of loyalty program milestones. As one of the largest coffee house chains in the world and the largest in Britain, Costa is the leader in the coffee loyalty programs. What’s more, it was the first points-based loyalty program in the coffee industry. 

To engage their growing customer base, Costa employs milestones within their loyalty programs. For example, to contribute to environmental conservation, the chain offers a free beverage to customers after only 5 drinks in a reusable cup. 

Costa rewards its members with a complimentary drink once they have bought 5 drinks using a reusable cup. 

The rules are simple. The members have a clear understanding of the specific actions required and their frequency to attain rewards. Additionally, it incorporates elements of gamification for added engagement. 

05. Digitize Loyalty Programs

Digitizing loyalty programs is crucial, as the majority of customers are now online, frequently using social media and browsing e-commerce sites. Enhancing the accessibility of a loyalty program through multiple channels increases the chances that customers will make purchases from your business.

As a business owner, understanding customer preferences and behaviors is crucial. By collecting and analyzing data, you can more accurately calculate key metrics such as Customer Lifetime Value (CLV), Customer Loyalty Index (CLI), and customer engagement scores. This leads to more tailored marketing strategies and improved customer engagement, helping you serve your customers better.

For customers, online loyalty programs offer convenience and personalization. They can easily access their rewards and account information anytime, anywhere, receiving personalized offers and recommendations. This enhances the overall experience, leading to greater customer satisfaction. When your customers are satisfied, they’re more likely to stick with your brand and become loyal. 

If you have a Shopify store or are thinking about starting one, implementing a loyalty program is crucial for the long-term financial success of your business. Since your main goal is to retain and acquire as many customers as possible, implementing a loyalty program is instrumental in achieving this objective.

Growave’s loyalty programs provide a powerful tool for increasing customer loyalty, boosting sales, and understanding your customers better, all of which contribute to the growth and success of your Shopify store. 

This impressive statistic highlights Growave as the optimal choice for Shopify stores seeking to boost customer loyalty and drive repeat business.


To build strong customer relationships and foster loyalty, businesses should focus on creating customer rewards programs that offer genuine value. An effective loyalty program should enhance the shopping experience through attractive benefits and rewards. This approach encompasses our comprehensive recommendations, from aligning the program's objectives with business goals to defining the rewards for customers, ensuring a mutually beneficial relationship. By implementing these strategies, businesses can build a loyal customer base that not only continues to patronize their services but also advocates for their brand, driving further growth and success.

No items found.
No items found.

Frequently asked questions

No items found.

Book a call with our experts

Book a call with our experts to learn more about how Growave can help you create a successful loyalty program.
Aika Growave Sales

Book a call with our experts

Unlock the Secrets of Ecommerce Success. Book a Call with Our Experts Now!
Aika Growave Sales

Book a call with our experts

Let our team show you the personalized approach to cart abandonment recovery.
Aika Growave Sales

Built on Trust, Driven by Results: See Why Users Choose Growave