How to Set Up a Loyalty Program on Shopify

Last updated on

Published on

September 2, 2025

•

minutes

Introduction

Loyalty programs are no longer optional—research shows most consumers are more likely to keep buying from brands that reward them, and merchants that keep customers have a clear path to predictable growth. At the same time, many merchants suffer from platform overload and fractured data: too many vendors, too many logins, and incentive programs that don’t connect to reviews, referrals, or social proof. That “app fatigue” costs time and revenue.

Short answer: Setting up a loyalty program on Shopify starts with a clear goal, a simple earning-and-redemption structure, and a retention platform that integrates loyalty with reviews, wishlists, referrals, and social proof. With the right plan and the right retention suite, you can launch a points-based or tiered program, sync it across online and in-store channels, and begin driving higher repeat purchase rates and average order value within weeks.

In this post we’ll cover the full path from strategy to launch and optimization. You’ll get practical, merchant-first advice on choosing the right program type, mapping earning and redemption rules, integrating across POS and email, promoting the program, measuring ROI, and avoiding common mistakes. Throughout, we’ll connect each challenge to how a unified retention solution can replace multiple disparate tools—delivering more growth with less stack.

Our main message: a well-designed loyalty program is a growth engine when it’s simple, measurable, and integrated with the rest of your marketing ecosystem.

Why Loyalty Programs Matter for Shopify Merchants

The value proposition: retention beats acquisition

Customer acquisition costs keep rising. Holding onto existing customers is more cost-efficient and profitable. Loyalty programs convert one-time buyers into repeat customers and increase customer lifetime value (LTV). They also turn engaged customers into advocates who refer new buyers.

Business outcomes you should target

Increase repeat purchase rate and purchase frequency.
Raise average order value by creating incentives to add items at checkout.
Create a growth channel for referrals and word-of-mouth.
Capture first-party data and link it to customer profiles for better personalization.
Generate more user-generated content and reviews that increase conversion.

Why integration matters (More Growth, Less Stack)

A loyalty program that lives in isolation delivers limited returns. Overlapping systems create friction: points don't sync between online and in-store, reviews don’t feed into rewards, and referral credits are manual. Our philosophy is "More Growth, Less Stack"—a single retention suite that combines Loyalty & Rewards with Reviews & UGC, Wishlists, Referrals, and Shoppable Social reduces complexity and multiplies impact. If your loyalty program is part of a unified ecosystem, each channel amplifies the others.

Types of Loyalty Programs and When to Use Them

Points-Based Programs

Points-based systems reward customers for purchases and actions with a currency they can redeem for discounts, products, or store credit.

When to use

You want a flexible system that encourages frequent engagement.
You want to reward both transactional and non-transactional behavior (reviews, follows, referrals).

Benefits

Familiar to customers.
Easy to scale and tweak.
Drives AOV with threshold-based redemptions.

Considerations

Points valuation must balance customer value with margins.
Clear communication is essential to avoid confusion about how many points equal a reward.

Tiered Programs

Tiered programs create levels (e.g., Bronze, Silver, Gold) with progressively better benefits.

When to use

You want to motivate customers to reach higher spend thresholds.
You sell products with repeat-purchase potential and want to spotlight VIP perks.

Benefits

Encourages higher spend and loyalty over time.
Creates exclusivity and better retention among top buyers.

Considerations

Tiers must offer genuinely valuable perks to justify the effort.
Monitor movement between tiers and avoid impossible thresholds.

Paid / Subscription Programs

Paid loyalty programs collect a membership fee for immediate, ongoing perks (fast shipping, exclusive discounts).

When to use

You have a customer base that values convenience or recurring benefits.
Your margins and unit economics support upfront membership revenue.

Benefits

Creates predictable revenue.
Members often spend more frequently.

Considerations

Must clearly demonstrate immediate value to justify the fee.
Trial strategies and staged rollouts help validate this model.

Value-Based Programs

Value-based programs align purchases with causes (donations per purchase, carbon offsets).

When to use

Your brand purpose is central to customer decision-making.
Your audience cares about social impact.

Benefits

Builds emotional loyalty and positive brand perception.
Differentiates your program beyond discounts.

Considerations

Transparency about allocation and impact is crucial.
You’ll need reporting to show results.

Planning Your Shopify Loyalty Program

Start with clear objectives

Before setting rules, define what success looks like. Examples of measurable goals:

Lift repeat purchase rate by X% in 90 days.
Increase AOV by Y% within the first six months.
Drive Z referrals per month.
Achieve N active members within launch month.

Having concrete KPIs steers every design choice and helps you measure ROI.

Know your customers and segments

Use your purchase data to identify high-value segments and behaviors you want to influence. Segmentation examples:

Occasional buyers who make a purchase every 6–12 months.
High-value repeat buyers who generate most revenue.
New customers who haven’t converted a second time.

Segment-based goals let you design rewards that move specific groups toward desired behaviors.

Map economics and margins

Points and rewards have a monetary cost. Build simple models that account for:

Average order value and margin per product category.
Expected redemption rates and breakage (points that aren’t redeemed).
The incremental revenue needed to offset reward costs.

A common rule: craft rewards so customers need to make 1–3 purchases before reaching a meaningful redemption.

Choose a program type that aligns with your goals

Match program type to objectives. For fast-moving consumables, points-based works well. For premium brands, tiers or paid memberships can be more effective. For purpose-driven brands, value-based programs help strengthen emotional bonds.

Define earning and redemption principles

Earning rules should be intuitive. Redemption should be achievable but not immediate on the first order.

Common earning actions to consider

Dollars spent (e.g., X points per $1).
Account creation and first order.
Product reviews or photo/video reviews.
Referrals that convert.
Social actions (follow, share) with careful validation.
Birthday bonus points or milestone rewards.

Redemption mechanics to consider

Fixed discount per points threshold.
Free product redemption for higher thresholds.
Exclusive access or early-bird perks for VIPs.
Minimum order value to use rewards (to protect margin).

Choosing Your Retention Solution on Shopify

What merchant-first criteria to evaluate

When selecting a retention suite, prioritize systems that:

Integrate deeply with Shopify and Shopify POS.
Combine loyalty with reviews, referrals, wishlists, and social to reduce tech overhead.
Offer mobile-friendly member experiences and a visible loyalty panel.
Provide analytics and segmentation for optimization.
Support POS and omnichannel points accrual and redemption.
Offer reliable merchant support and transparent pricing.

We recommend evaluating how the solution helps you deliver a branded, intuitive experience rather than just a points ledger. For a unified approach to loyalty and retention, explore our Loyalty & Rewards features to see how integrated tools perform across channels.

Installation and setup basics

A retention suite that’s built for Shopify typically installs quickly and places a branded widget or panel on your storefront to display points and rewards. For merchants that want a simple install path, you can always install Growave from the Shopify marketplace to get a fully integrated retention solution.

Integration checklist

Make sure the solution you choose connects to:

Shopify customer profiles and order history.
Your email and SMS platform for automated messaging.
Shopify POS for in-store point accrual and redemptions.
Reviews and UGC tools so customers can earn for leaving proof of purchase.

For a unified retention experience, consider how your loyalty program will work with social reviews and UGC—displaying reviews alongside rewards creates stronger conversion signals and gives customers multiple reasons to engage. Learn how to display customer reviews and UGC as part of your retention strategy.

Step-By-Step: How to Set Up a Loyalty Program on Shopify

Prepare your store data

Start by auditing your current customer data:

Identify repeat customers, AOV, and frequency metrics.
Pull a list of customers who have left reviews or referred friends.
Note any existing discount codes or promotions that might interact with rewards.

This baseline helps you measure change after launch.

Configure program structure in your retention suite

Set up the basics:

Program name and branded currency (e.g., “Stars,” “Points,” or a unique name that matches your voice).
Clear program description and rules visible to customers.
Earning actions and points-per-dollar rules.
Redemption options and point-to-dollar conversion.

Make the currency memorable—don’t just call it “points.” A branded currency can increase perceived value and emotional connection.

Define default earning rules

Create a straightforward earning model to start:

Offer sign-up points to jumpstart engagement.
Reward purchases at a simple rate (for example, a small % back as points).
Add social or review bonuses only if you can validate actions reliably.
Reserve special multipliers for promotional windows (holidays, product launches).

Keep the initial rule set small to avoid confusion; you can expand after launch.

Set redemption rules tied to business economics

Align reward values with margin:

Decide on the point-to-dollar conversion that returns 3–10% back to customers depending on margins.
Consider minimum spend thresholds to redeem points to protect profit.
Offer a mix of small, achievable rewards and aspirational redemptions.

Monitor breakage—points never redeemed—which is a component of your program’s effective cost.

Build the member experience (UX)

Customers should be able to:

See points balance on every page via a loyalty panel.
View how to earn and redeem points easily.
Redeem during checkout without friction.

Make your loyalty panel mobile-friendly and persistent across devices. If you use a retention suite, this should be part of the setup flow. For example, you can use the loyalty panel to showcase popular rewards and upcoming VIP perks.

Connect to Shopify POS for physical stores

If you sell in-store, ensure points sync to in-store purchases and redemptions. With POS integration, staff can look up a customer, view available rewards, and apply redemptions at checkout—delivering a consistent omnichannel experience. For merchants on Shopify POS, install the retention solution from the marketplace to connect your online and physical channels seamlessly.

Configure automated communications

Integrate loyalty messaging with email and SMS to increase engagement:

Welcome email with sign-up points and a CTA to redeem.
Points-balance reminders (e.g., “You’re 50 points away from $10 off”).
Birthday messages with bonus points.
Tier-upgrade and VIP-only offers.

Automation drives participation without manual effort.

Test the flow internally

Before launching, test every scenario:

New member sign-up and points award.
Purchase accrual across product types.
Redemption during checkout and order returns handling.
POS lookup and redemption in-store.
Email and SMS triggers.

Testing prevents embarrassing customer issues and ensures staff are confident supporting the program.

Launch and promote

Make the program visible across channels:

Add a prominent banner and a dedicated loyalty page.
Highlight membership benefits in cart and checkout.
Email your current customers with an incentive to join.
Run a short-term bonus points campaign to drive early traction.

Visibility and a compelling initial incentive will accelerate signups.

Designing Rewards That Drive Behavior

Balance immediate gratification and long-term gains

Offer small, easy-to-redeem rewards to hook customers and aspirational rewards to motivate repeat purchases. For instance, a small percentage off for low-point redemptions and exclusive product redemptions for higher values.

Incentivize high-value behaviors

Tie earning opportunities to actions that drive value:

Extra points for purchasing high-margin SKUs.
Double points for add-on categories to increase AOV.
Bonus points for referrals that convert to customers.

Make VIP treatment meaningful

VIP benefits should feel exclusive and special:

Early access to new products.
Free or discounted shipping.
Dedicated support or gift-wrapping.
Invite-only events or limited-edition products.

Use expirations strategically

Expirations create urgency but can erode trust if perceived as unfair. Consider:

Expiring points only after long periods of inactivity.
Triggering point reminders before expiration to encourage returns.

Avoid common reward pitfalls

Don’t make redemption thresholds so high they’re unreachable.
Avoid overly complex earning rules that confuse customers.
Don’t underdeliver on promised perks; keep tech and fulfillment aligned.

Omnichannel and POS Considerations

Why omnichannel matters

Customers shop across devices and channels. Points that live only online or only in-store create friction and resentment. A unified retention suite ensures points are visible and redeemable wherever customers shop, strengthening loyalty.

POS integration checklist

Customer lookup capabilities at checkout.
Real-time points balance and eligibility display.
Seamless redemption applied to orders and receipts.
Staff training materials and quick-reference guides.

Handling returns and refunds

Decide how returns affect points:

Reverse points awarded when items are refunded.
Revoke redemptions used on refunded purchases.
Communicate these rules clearly in your terms.

Designing returns and point reversals into your system prevents abuse and protects margins.

Promoting Your Loyalty Program

On-site discoverability

Persistent loyalty panel that shows balance and CTA to join.
Dedicated loyalty landing page that explains benefits and rules.
Checkout banners calling out points earned on this purchase.

Email and SMS campaigns

Welcome series: sign-up reward and next steps.
Reminder campaigns: unused points, approaching tier upgrade.
Event-triggered messages: birthday bonus, member-only sales.

Off-site and social promotion

Promote with social posts and story highlights.
Use email footers and welcome pop-ups.
Feature loyalty benefits in product pages and ads.

When you promote loyalty alongside social proof, you increase both signups and conversions—displaying customer reviews and UGC next to loyalty benefits is especially effective for driving trust.

Incentivized referral programs

Referrals turn customers into advocates. A referral reward that benefits both referrer and referee converts better. Ensure referral links are trackable and you have fraud prevention in place.

Measurement, Optimization, and KPIs

Core metrics to monitor

Enrollment rate and active member percentage.
Repeat purchase rate and frequency among members.
Average order value for members vs non-members.
Redemption rate and breakage.
Customer lifetime value (LTV) uplift.
Cost of rewards as a percentage of incremental revenue.

Track these metrics over time and by segment to understand who the program serves best.

Common optimization levers

Adjust point valuations or earning rates to recalibrate economics.
Introduce targeted bonus campaigns to re-engage dormant members.
Add tier benefits for high-potential customers.
A/B test messages, panel placement, and reward offerings.

Small changes often yield outsized returns when they address friction or clarity issues.

Attribution and incremental lift

Measure incremental lift by comparing behavior before and after enrollment and using control groups where possible. This helps quantify the true ROI of the loyalty program versus natural repeat behavior.

Common Mistakes and How to Avoid Them

Overcomplicating earning rules

Keep earning actions easy to understand. Overly complex rules reduce participation and increase support volume.

How to fix

Simplify the default earning rate.
Use layered promotional multipliers for short-term campaigns.

Ignoring the member experience

If customers don’t know how many points they have or how to redeem them, engagement will drop.

How to fix

Make the loyalty panel visible on every page.
Show "how close you are" banners in the cart.

Failing to integrate with POS and reviews

Disconnected systems create inconsistent experiences.

How to fix

Choose a retention suite that supports omnichannel points and links with social reviews so you can reward UGC directly.

Underestimating program economics

Not modeling margins and redemption costs leads to unsustainable programs.

How to fix

Create a simple P&L for expected redemption patterns.
Start conservative and iterate.

Advanced Tactics for Scaling Your Program

Personalization and behavior-based offers

Use purchase history to send hyper-relevant rewards:

Personalized redemption options based on favorite categories.
Time-limited multipliers for items customers frequently buy.

Gamification without complexity

Introduce simple streaks or milestone rewards that reward repeat visits without overly complex rules. For example, reward a customer for making purchases across three consecutive months.

Cross-sell and replenishment nudges

Use loyalty balances to encourage replenishment purchases with small, targeted discounts that won’t cannibalize full-price sales.

Using UGC and reviews to boost program value

Reward customers for photo and video reviews to build social proof. Display that content near high-converting pages to amplify trust and conversion. Integrating reviews into your loyalty program turns advocacy into measurable revenue.

Learn how to display customer reviews and UGC and tie them back to rewards to create a virtuous retention loop.

Launch Checklist (Pre-Launch to Day 90)

Pre-launch

Define goals and KPIs.
Model economics and margin impact.
Create branded currency and program name.
Draft clear terms and help center content.

Launch week

Enable loyalty panel and sign-up bonus.
Run a launch email with enrollment incentives.
Monitor sign-up rates and any technical issues.

First 30 days

Push reminder automations and targeted bonus points.
Collect initial feedback and fix UX friction.

Days 30–90

Evaluate KPIs against targets.
Introduce targeted campaigns for high-potential segments.
Iterate rewards and communications.

How Growave Helps You Build a Sustainable Loyalty Engine

We build for merchants first, with the belief that retention should be simple, integrated, and results-driven. Our retention suite combines Loyalty & Rewards with Reviews & UGC, Wishlists, Referrals, and Shoppable Social to remove complexity and deliver more growth for less stack.

Key capabilities that matter to merchants

Branded loyalty panels and customizable rewards to match your voice.
Omnichannel points and seamless Shopify POS integration.
Integrated review collection and UGC workflows to reward advocacy.
Built-in referral mechanics that reward both referrer and referee.
Analytics and segmentation tools to optimize program economics.

If you want to explore how these features map to your store, see our dedicated page about our Loyalty & Rewards features to understand the full range of configuration options. You can also learn more about how our Reviews & UGC tools help you collect and display social proof that boosts conversion and feeds your loyalty program.

We’re trusted by over 15,000 brands and carry a 4.8-star rating on Shopify—evidence that merchant-first design and integrated retention strategies deliver results.

If you prefer to see the product in action, you can install Growave from the Shopify marketplace to get hands-on or check our plans and pricing to evaluate fit for your business.

Legal, Taxes, and Fraud Prevention

Terms and disclosures

Clearly state terms for points, expirations, and redemptions in your FAQ and checkout pages. Transparency reduces disputes and support requests.

Tax treatment

Treat reward redemptions consistently with local tax rules. Consult your accountant to determine tax handling for discounts and store credits.

Fraud considerations

Monitor for referral and points-abuse patterns. Use device and account checks and require verified purchases for certain actions. Tighten rules for earning points from social actions if abuse appears.

Realistic Timeline and Resources

Typical timeline to launch a basic but polished loyalty program:

Week 0–1: Strategy, economic modeling, and selection of retention solution.
Week 1–2: Setup of earning/redeeming rules, loyalty panel, and automations.
Week 2–3: POS integration, staff training, and testing.
Week 3–4: Soft launch and promotion; monitor and fix early issues.

Resource needs

A merchant lead to define strategy and content.
A developer or support for POS/UI tweaks (often minimal).
Marketing time for launch campaigns and communications.
Customer support training for in-store and online teams.

Troubleshooting Common Launch Issues

Issue: Low initial enrollment

Make the sign-up reward compelling and easy to claim.
Increase visibility with banners and checkout reminders.

Issue: Confusion about how points convert

Add a clear example (e.g., “100 points = $5 off”) on the loyalty page and in the loyalty panel.

Issue: Points not applying in POS

Confirm real-time syncing settings and staff workflows.
Ensure customer accounts are linked across channels.

Issue: High redemption costs

Revisit point valuations, add minimum spend thresholds, or shift to experiential rewards that are perceived as high value but low cost.

Conclusion

A loyalty program on Shopify can be a powerful engine for sustainable growth when it’s built with clear goals, simple rules, and tight integration across channels. Start small, measure carefully, and iterate quickly. By choosing a merchant-first retention suite that combines loyalty with reviews, referrals, and shoppable social, you reduce tech complexity and unlock compounding effects across retention channels.

Get started today—explore our plans and start a 14-day free trial to see how our retention suite replaces multiple platforms and helps you turn retention into predictable growth. View plans and pricing

FAQ

How quickly can I expect to see results from a loyalty program?

You can see early effects—like increased enrollment and minor lifts in repeat purchases—within weeks if you promote the program effectively. Significant LTV improvements typically appear over months as members climb tiers and change buying habits.

Do I need Shopify Plus to run a loyalty program?

No—you don’t need Shopify Plus. Many merchants successfully run loyalty programs on standard Shopify plans. However, some advanced integrations or automations may be easier on higher-tier plans.

How should I value points relative to dollars?

A common approach is to return between 3–10% back in points value, adjusted for margins. Set redemption thresholds so customers need a couple of purchases before reaching a meaningful reward, and track breakage to improve economics.

Can loyalty and reviews be combined?

Yes. Rewarding customers for verified photo and video reviews increases social proof and conversion. Integrating review rewards into your loyalty system creates a virtuous loop that amplifies both retention and acquisition.

Frequently asked questions

No items found.

Best Reads

No items found.

Trusted by over 15000 brands running on Shopify

4.8

4.9

4.6